Table 4.
A comparative overview of the advantages, disadvantages, and applications of experimental models for the study of NEC
Model Organism | Advantages | Disadvantages | Applications |
---|---|---|---|
Rats | Low cost. | Lack of readily available transgenic strains. | Biomarker identification. |
High litter size. | Marked difference in bacterial/endotoxin tolerance between rats and human (increased tolerance in rats). | Investigation of pathogenesis and disease mechanisms. | |
Ready availability. | Uncertain relevance to human disease. | Drug discovery. | |
Ease of disease induction. | |||
Uniform genetic backgrounds. | |||
Short gestational period. | |||
Mice | Low cost. | Difficulty in feeding and handling small and fragile pups. | Biomarker identification. |
High litter size. | Investigation of pathogenesis and disease mechanisms. | ||
Ready availability. | |||
Ease of disease induction. | Drug discovery. | ||
Uniform genetic backgrounds. | |||
Short gestational period. | |||
High genetic similarity. | |||
Availability of knockout strains. | |||
Sophisticated transgenic approaches. | |||
Piglets | High degree of anatomic, developmental, nutritional, functional and physiological similarity of the gastrointestinal tract with human infants. | High cost. | Drug discovery. |
Similar size to human preterm infants. | Difficulty in maintaining and feeding a group of premature piglets. | Validation of biochemical pathways. | |
Variability of genetic background. | Study of pathogenesis. | ||
Need for a well-equipped surgical facility to perform cesarean section and safely manage a litter of piglets. | Evaluation of specific feeding regimens. | ||
Preclinical drug studies. | |||
Development of early noninvasive spectroscopic diagnostic methods. | |||
Hamsters and rabbits | Relatively large size. | High cost relative to rats and mice. | Underlying mechanisms of disease. |
Ease of handling. | Variability of genetic background. | ||
Nematode (Caenorhabditis elegans) | Relatively low cost. | Lacks many physiological and dietary features of mammals, making the clinical and scientific relevance to NEC uncertain. | The study of single cells and cell-microbial interactions. |
Easy genetic manipulation. | |||
Well-characterized genome. | |||
Epithelialized gastrointestinal tract. | |||
Invertebrate (Drosophila) | Low cost. | Relevance to disease in mammalian systems is uncertain. | Study of underlying mechanisms. |
Easy genetic manipulation. |