Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Jun 5.
Published in final edited form as: Trauma Violence Abuse. 2012 Dec 26;14(2):168–185. doi: 10.1177/1524838012470034

Table 1.

Exclusion criteria for systematic review, including the number of studies not meeting each criterion.

Inclusion Criterion Number not meeting criterion Articles Remaining
Published after 1990 in a peer-reviewed journal
Article must be published in 1990 or afterwards in a peer-reviewed journal
0 576
Written in English
Article must be written in English
15 561
Research
Article must be the product of original research, therefore excluding systematic reviews, meta-analyses, expert opinions, journalistic articles, etc.
132 429
US and Territories Population
The population must be drawn from the United States or its Territories
81 348
MSM Population at least in part
The population must include men who have sex with men, and MSM must be analyzed as separately delineated group within the study
156 192
No one <15 years old
No member of the sample may be younger than 15 years old in order to avoid childhood sexual abuse misclassification bias
23 169
Intimate Partner Violence Measured
Intimate Partner Violence, broadly defined, must be measured. A variety of terms may be used for IPV, such as domestic violence, violence victimization, partner abuse, etc. are eligible. The violence measured must be relationship violence, to the exclusion of, for example, homophobic attacks.
75 94
Measure IPV apart from Childhood Sexual Abuse
The study must not be focused solely on childhood sexual abuse.
56 38
Use of non-specific population
The study population must not be a specific population, such as injection drug users, or persons accessing domestic violence assistance resources
4 34
Report IPV as a prevalence and/or correlates of IPV
IPV must be reported as a prevalence and/or associations between IPV and unprotected anal intercourse specifically among MSM must be reported.
2 32
Sample size over 50
The sample size of MSM must be over 50 persons regardless of the size of the entire study population
4 28