Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Jun 12.
Published in final edited form as: Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009 Apr 15;(2):CD007313. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007313.pub2
Methods Study Design: Randomised, double-blind, parallel group study over a 12 month period in 41 centres in 12 countries (between Jan 2001 and Jan 2003). In the 14-18 day runin patients used pre-study ICS with terbutaline for symptom relief (LABA had to be discontinued at least 3 days before run-in)
Participants Children in Study: 341 asthmatic children aged 4-11 years with asthma uncontrolled on ICS (200-500 mcg/day) and a history of at least one “clinically important” exacerbation in the past year.
Mean age: 8 years. Mean morning PEF: 220 L/min. FEV1 76% predicted pre bronchodilator. Mean ICS dose at enrolment 315 mcg/day. Hospital admission for asthma in the past year: unknown proportion. Course of oral steroids for asthma in past year: unknown proportion
Inclusion Criteria: Aged 4-11 years, with a constant dose of ICS (200-500 mcg/day) at least 3 months. Prebronchodilator FEV1 of 60-100% predicted normal value and at least 12% reversibility following Terbutaline. To be included patients had to need at least 8 rescue inhalations in the last 10 days of run-in. Children using seven or more rescue inhalations in a single day or with an exacerbation during run-in were not randomised
Interventions 1. Budesonide 100 mcg (80 mcg delivered dose) and Formoterol 4.5 mcg in the evening and as needed (one maintenance and one relief Turbuhaler)
2. Budesonide 100 mcg (80 mcg delivered dose) and Formoterol 4.5 mcg in the evening and Terbutaline as needed (one maintenance and one relief Turbuhaler)
3. Budesonide 400 mcg (320 mcg delivered dose) in the evening and Terbutaline as needed (one maintenance and one relief Turbuhaler)
Outcomes Primary outcome
  • Time to first severe exacerbations

Secondary outcomes
  • Number of severe exacerbations

  • Time to mild exacerbations

  • Number of mild exacerbations

  • Symptom free days

  • QOL scores

  • No particular variable was chosen to assess safety.

Exacerbation Definition: Severe - Deterioration in asthma requiring hospital or emergency room treatment, or oral steroids (or an increase in ICS or other additional treatment) or morning PEF 70% or less of baseline on two consecutive days. Severe exacerbations requiring medical intervention were analysed separately. Mild exacerbation day - PEF 80% or less of baseline, relief medication 2 or more inhalations above baseline, or awakenings due to asthma. Mild exacerbation defined as 2 consecutive mild exacerbation days using the same criteria
Additional Data
Data on file from AstraZeneca indicate that 0/118 children under the age of 12 years had at least one asthma related SAE on SMART and 2/106 on Pulmicort. Data on children given a course of oral corticosteroids has not been obtained
Notes Adverse Events:SAE data given (2,16,5) of these (0,7,2) were related to asthma. Change from baseline nights with awakenings were the same in both groups, P value in the paper not used as it related to post treatment levels not changes. No SD data published in the paper with respect to growth comparing budesonide/formoterol to Terbutaline as reliever, so SD calculated from the other comparisons presented
Risk of bias
Item Authors’ judgement Description
Adequate sequence generation? Yes See STAY - Adults
Allocation concealment? Unclear See STAY - Adults
Blinding?
All outcomes
Yes See STAY - Adults
Incomplete outcome data addressed?
All outcomes
Yes See STAY - Adults