Skip to main content
. 2014 Jun 16;9(6):e99392. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0099392

Table 2. Characteristics of observational studies included in the qualitative analysis.

Author Year Country N Population Co-morbidities Samples analyzed Molecular assays Reported outcomes
LOS Death ICU Oxygen req.
Aramburo [35] 2011 US 80 Children <5yo IC, C-R NPs RT-PCR yes yes no no
Camargo [36] 2012 Brazil 41 Adults & Children IC, C-R, Other NPs RT-PCR no yes yes no
Calvo [33] 2008 Spain 172 Children <2yo C-R, Other NPAs RT-PCR yes no no no
Canducci [1] 2008 Italy 150 Children <2yo Undefined conditions NPAs RT-PCR yes no no yes
Choi [16] 2010 S. Korea 72 Adults IC, C-R, Other NPs and BAL RT-PCR no yes no no
Cilla [37] 2008 Spain 178 Children <3yo IC, C-R, Other NPAs RT-PCR kit, Qiagen yes no no yes
De Paullis [34] 2011 Brazil 176 Children <2yo C-R, Other NPAs RT-PCR yes yes yes no
Do [21] 2011 Vietnam 222 Children <15yo None NPAs, TS, NS RT-PCR kit, Seeplex yes no yes yes
Esper [17] 2011 US 226 Adults & Children None NPAs RT-PCR kit, Invitrogen no no no yes
Franz [18] 2010 Germany 375 Children <16yo C-R, Other NPAs RT-PCR yes no no yes
Garcia Garcia [32] 2006 Spain 69 Children <2yo C-R, Other NPAs RT-PCR kit, Qiagen OneStep yes no no no
Garcia Garcia [38] 2010 Spain 539 Children <14yo Other NPAs RT-PCR kit, Qiagen OneStep yes no no yes
Gerna [22] 2008 Italy 47 Children <2yo None NPAs RT-PCR yes no no no
Guerrier [15] 2013 Cambodia 551 Children <5yo C-R NPAs RT-PCR kit, Biomérieux yes yes no yes
Marcos [39] 2009 Spain 181 Adults IC, C-R, Other NPs and OPs xTAG RVP FAST, Luminex yes no no no
Marguet [40] 2009 France 126 Children <2yo Other NPAs RT-PCR yes no no no
Martin [19] 2012 US 566 Children IC, C-R, Other Nasal wash RT-PCR yes no yes yes
Nascimento [14] 2010 Brazil 77 Children <2yo C-R, Other NPAs RT-PCR kit, Qiagen no no yes no
Nascimento [2] 2011 Brazil 11 Children <5yo none NPAs RT-PCR yes no no no
Prill [23] 2012 US 113 Children <5yo C-R, Other Nasal & TS RT-PCR yes no yes yes
Rhedin [24] 2012 Sweden 308 Children <17yo IC, C-R NPAs, NPs, BAL RT-PCR kit, Qiagen yes yes yes no

Legend: N = number, LOS = Length of stay, ICU = admission to the intensive care unit, ILI: influenza-like illness, CAP: community acquired pneumonia; IC: immunocompromised; C-R: cardio-respiratory ARI: acute respiratory infections; NPAs: Nasopharyngeal aspirates; NPs: nasopharyngeal swabs; Ops: oropharyngeal swabs; TS: throat swabs: RT-PCR: real-time PCR. Studies, which included commercial assays (RT-PCR) were labeled as RT-PCR kit, with the mention of the manufacturer.