Skip to main content
. 2014 Apr 15;8(4):NE01–NE06. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2014/8269.4285

[Table/Fig-4]:

Outcome of relevant studies in favour of LCS

Sl No. Study Total pts Laparoscopic group Open Group Conclusion
1 Jacob et al., [2] 219 111 108 Reduced blood loss
  • Early return of intestinal mortality,

  • Lower overall morbidity and shorter hospital stay(HS) in comparison with open surgery

2 COST [5] 872 435 437
  • Longer operation time(OpT) but quick recovery and shorter HS

  • No significant difference in morbidity and mortality, tumour recurrence or overall survival

  • Safe in expert hands

3 MRC CLASSIC Trial [6] 794 526 268
  • LCS as effective as open surgery

  • No difference in hospital mortality or quality of life

  • Increased incidence of positive circumferential resection margin but not statistically significant

4 COLOR Trial [7] 1248 627 621
  • Longer OpT but less blood loss, early recovery of bowel function, fewer analgesic requirement and shorter HS

  • No difference in radicality of tumour resection.

5 Martel G et al., [8] Meta-analysis 5782 3,031 2,751
  • No difference in recurrence rate, overall mortality and distance metastasis when comparing with open surgery

Sl No. Study Total pts Laparoscopic group Open Group Conclusion
6 Prakash et al., [10] 124 62 62
  • Reduced blood loss

  • Shorter ICU stay

  • Early resumption of oral feeds,

  • shorter hospital stay(HS)

7 Prakash et al., [11] 265 265 -
  1. As experience improved more difficult cases and complex laparoscopic colorectal resection performed

8 Palanivelu et al., [12] 170 170 -
  • Laparoscopic anterior resection is possible for all levels of rectal tumours with preserving adequate sphincter function and waiting oncological safety.

9 Palanivelu et al., [13] 11 11 -
  • Single incision multiport laparoscopic surgery is feasible without extra cost of specialised ports of instruments.

10 Puntambekar S et al., [14] 37 37 -
  • With introduction of Robotic Assisted Laparoscopic Surgery, indication for such operation can be widened and difficult operations can be performed easier.

11 Haas EM et al., [27] 54 54 (SILC) -
  • SILC is feasible with no increase in operative complications or harmful results even in the early phase of learning curve Anastomotic leak

12 Dehni N et al., [28] 258 Not specified Not specified
  • Without faecal diversion-17%

  • With faecal diversion-6.6%