1 |
Jacob et al., [2] |
219 |
111 |
108 |
Reduced blood loss
Early return of intestinal mortality,
Lower overall morbidity and shorter hospital stay(HS) in comparison with open surgery
|
2 |
COST [5] |
872 |
435 |
437 |
Longer operation time(OpT) but quick recovery and shorter HS
No significant difference in morbidity and mortality, tumour recurrence or overall survival
Safe in expert hands
|
3 |
MRC CLASSIC Trial [6] |
794 |
526 |
268 |
LCS as effective as open surgery
No difference in hospital mortality or quality of life
Increased incidence of positive circumferential resection margin but not statistically significant
|
4 |
COLOR Trial [7] |
1248 |
627 |
621 |
Longer OpT but less blood loss, early recovery of bowel function, fewer analgesic requirement and shorter HS
No difference in radicality of tumour resection.
|
5 |
Martel G et al., [8] Meta-analysis |
5782 |
3,031 |
2,751 |
|
Sl No. |
Study |
Total pts |
Laparoscopic group |
Open Group |
Conclusion |
6 |
Prakash et al., [10] |
124 |
62 |
62 |
|
7 |
Prakash et al., [11] |
265 |
265 |
- |
As experience improved more difficult cases and complex laparoscopic colorectal resection performed
|
8 |
Palanivelu et al., [12] |
170 |
170 |
- |
|
9 |
Palanivelu et al., [13] |
11 |
11 |
- |
|
10 |
Puntambekar S et al., [14] |
37 |
37 |
- |
|
11 |
Haas EM et al., [27] |
54 |
54 (SILC) |
- |
|
12 |
Dehni N et al., [28] |
258 |
Not specified |
Not specified |
|