Table 5.
Journal endorsement information for evaluations assessing BMJ economics, CONSORT extension for abstracts, CONSORT extension for harms, CONSORT extension for herbal interventions, and PRISMA reporting guidelines
| Author, year | Endorsing journals that published assessed studies | Extent of endorsement | Date of endorsement provided |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMJ economic guidelines, 1996 | |||
| Herman, 2005122* † | BMJ | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| Jefferson, 1998123 | BMJ | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| CONSORT extension for abstracts, 2008 | |||
| Ghimire, 2014146 | Lancet | Suggests use | By journal, email |
| CONSORT extension for harms, 2004 | |||
| Haidich, 2011124*† | Annals of Internal Medicine | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| The Lancet | Submit checklist | By journal, email | |
| Turner, 2011125*† | The American Journal of Gastroenterology | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| American Journal of Kidney Diseases | Suggests use | By journal, email | |
| Applied Health Economics and Health Policy | Suggests use | By journal, email | |
| JAMA | Submit checklist | Not provided | |
| Phytomedicine | Suggests use | Not provided | |
| Peron, 2014141 † | Lancet | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| Lancet Oncology | Submit checklist | By journal, email | |
| Cornelius, 2013142 † | Lancet | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| Lee, 2008126 | BMJ | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| CONSORT extension for herbal interventions, 2006 | |||
| Ernst, 2011127 † | Annals of Internal Medicine | Suggests use | Not provided |
| PRISMA, 2009 | |||
| Tunis, 2013143*† | Radiology | Suggests use | Unknown based on information given |
| Panic, 2013145* | Alimentary Pharmacology and Therapeutics | Extent of endorsement at time of author’s analysis unknown (all journals) | Provided by author (all journals) |
| American Journal of Gastroenterology | |||
| BMC Gastroenterology | |||
| Colorectal Disease | |||
| Diseases of the Colon and Rectum | |||
| Gut | |||
| Gut Pathogens | |||
| Hepatitis Monthly | |||
| HPB | |||
| Fleming, 2013144* | American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics | Submit checklist | By journal, email |
| Angle Orthodontist | Suggests use | Not provided | |
| European Journal of Orthodontics | Submit checklist | By journal, email | |
| Journal of Orthodontics | Suggests use | By journal, email | |
*Evaluations included in quantitative analysis.
†Endorsing versus non-endorsing journals comparison only.