Table 1. Characteristics of studies in this meta-analysis.
Author (Ref) | Mean/median age (years) [range] | M+/M– |
Specimen types | Methods | Methylation site | RUNX3 expression | Quality score | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patients | Controls | |||||||
Hou DR et al. (34) 2009, China | 55 [38-64] | 30/32 | 11/51 | Tissue | MSP | Promoter hypermethylation | Negative | 6 |
Zhang Y et al. (31) 2011, China | 59 [35-80] | 18/60 | 8/70 | Tissue | MSP | Cpg islands | Not reported | 5 |
Yu GP et al. (32) 2012, China | 57 [38-72] | 26/32 | 10/48 | Tissue | MSP | Promoter | Not reported | 7 |
Lu DG et al. (33) 2011, China | 59.6 [42-75] | 25/37 | 0/46 | Serum* | MSP | Promoter hypermethylation | Not reported | 5 |
Yanagawa N et al. (35) 2003, Japan | 67.3 [39-86] | 15/60 | 2/73 | Tissue | MSP | Promoter hypermethylation | Not reported | 6 |
Suzuki M et al. (36) 2005, Japan | 65 | 25/92 | 0/51 | Tissue | MSP | Cpg islands | Not reported | 4 |
Yanagawa N et al. (37) 2007, Japan | 68.1 [39-86] | 25/76 | 3/98 | Tissue | MSP | Promoter hypermethylation | Not reported | 8 |
Yoshino M et al. (38) 2009, Japan | 63.2 [44-90] | 9/35 | 2/30 | Tissue | MSP | Cpg islands | Not reported | 8 |
Li QL et al. (39) 2004, Korea | Not reported | 6/19 | 0/25 | Tissue | MSP | Promoter | Not reported | 7 |
Chung JH et al. (40) 2011, Korea | 59.2 [34-85] | 29/61 | 0/20 | Tissue | q-MSP | Cpg islands | Not reported | 8 |
Tan SH et al. (23) 2007, Singapore | Not reported | 11/9 | 0/10 | Serum* | MSP | Promoter hypermethylation | Not reported | 4 |
Omar MF et al. (41) 2012, Singapore | Not reported | 3/6 | 3/2 | Tissue | MSP | Promoter hypermethylation | Positive | 4 |
Licchesi JD et al. (42) 2008, USA | 69.6 [48-80] | 17/1 | 13/33 | Tissue | MSP | Promoter hypermethylationhy | Negative | 6 |
M+, the number of tissues with methylation; M–, the number of tissues with unmethylation. *, peripheral serum.