Model steady states at 1,000 Ma as a function of terrestrial weatherability, W. Line type shows choices for the dependency of seafloor weathering rate on atmospheric CO2 concentration. Rates of silicate and seafloor weathering (A), relative ocean phosphate concentration (B), organic carbon burial rate (C), the fraction of carbon buried organically (D), relative atmospheric oxygen (E), and CO2 concentrations (F). Weatherability is defined as the global weathering flux that would be expected under present-day conditions, relative (i.e., normalized) to the present-day flux. Gray vertical line denotes best guess for W at 1,000 Ma. We assume a relative spreading rate and solar forcing of 1.83 (37) and 0.923 (38), respectively.