Table 1.
Study/Reference | Design | N | Duration | Population | Intervention | Primary outcome | Results | Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Koenig 2008 (36) | RDBPG | 647 | 16 weeks | Uncontrolled on low-moderate ICS but controlled on FSC 100/50 | Step-down to FP100, SAL 50 or Montelukast | PEF | Control deteriorated in all step-down groups | |
Fowler 2002 (42) | RDBPG | 39 | 12 weeks | Mod-severe asthma | 1000 BDP BID X 4 weeks then BDP 200 2 x daily or FSC 100/50 2x daily | PC20 | Doubling dose improvement in MCT with FSC greater than either BDP dose | Lung function and QOL better on FSC vs BDP step-down |
Bateman 2006 (43) | RDBPG | 484 | 24 weeks | Moderate asthma, well-controlled | FSC 250/50 stepped down to FSC 100/50 vs FP 250 | PEF | PEF lower in FP vs FSC | Symptoms, rescue albuterol and control better on FSC than FP |
Godard 2008 (44) | RDBPG | 473 | 6 months | Well controlled on FSC 250/50 | Decrease to FSC 100/50 vs FP 250 | PEF | FSC 100/50 similar to 250/50 but better than FP 250 | |
Reddel 2010 (45) | RDBPG | 82 | 13 months | FSC 500/50 | 500/50 vs FP 500 and down titrated every 8 weeks | Mean daily FP dose | No difference in mean daily dose FP but final dose lower in FSC | Question if patients were over treated |
RDBPG=randomized, double blinded, parallel group; BDP=beclomethasone dipropionate; ICS=inhaled corticosteroid; BHR=bronchial hyperreactivity; CS=corticosteroids