Skip to main content
. 2014 Jul 8;9(7):e99804. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0099804

Table 1. Randomized controlled trials according to basis of hip implant comparison.

Basis of comparison Study ID
Cup fixation (cemented vs. cementless) Bjorgul 2010 [22]
Angadi 2012 [24]
Cup liner bearing surface (XLPE vs. non-XLPE) McCalden 2009 [25]
Engh 2012 [26]
Cup shell design (porous-coated vs. arc-deposited HA-coated) Capello 2008 [28]
Cup and femoral stem fixation (cemented vs. cementless) Corten 2011 [32]
Femoral head size (36 mm vs. 28 mm) Howie 2012 [36]
Femoral head bearing (oxinium vs. CoCr) Lewis 2008 [37]
Femoral head-on-cup liner bearing
Ceramic-on-ceramic vs. ceramic-on-PE Amanatullah 2011 [38]
Ceramic-on-ceramic vs. CoCr-on-PE Capello 2008 [28]
Steel-on-PE vs. CoCr-on-PE vs. oxinium-on-PE vs. CoCr-on-XLPE vs. oxinium-on-XLPE Kadar 2011 [39]
Ceramic-on-ceramic vs. CoCr-on-XLPE Bascarevic 2010 [43]
Femoral stem composition (CoCr vs. titanium) Healy 2009 [40]
Femoral stem design (short metaphyseal-fitting vs. conventional metaphyseal- and diaphyseal-filling) Kim 2011 [41]
Femoral stem fixation (cemented vs. cementless) Kim 2011 [42]

XLPE = cross-linked polyethylene; PE = polyethylene; HA = hydroxyapatite; CoCr = cobalt chrome.