Table 1.
Test | Scope | Indication | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|---|
CMA | Targeted and untargeted (includes known disease loci as well as a survey across the chromosomes) | Unexplained epilepsy, especially with intellectual disability and/or autism Suspected chromosomal microdeletion or duplication syndrome |
Simultaneous targeted and untargeted approach May provide information about regions of homozygosity in consanguineous individuals, thereby possibly suggesting specific genes Relatively fast (few weeks) |
Rarely, can miss a chromosomal rearrangement such as a ring chromosome abnormality, but high-resolution clinical CMA typically detects small deletions at the site of rearrangements |
Karyotyping | Untargeted | Suspected monosomy, trisomy or chromosomal rearrangement; maternal history of recurrent pregnancy losses; generally recommended if strong suspicion and CMA result is negative | Fast (few days) | Lower resolution than CMA |
Single-gene testing | Targeted | Syndromes usually associated with specific gene(s) | Faster and less expensive than gene-panel testing | Not all commercially available tests include deletion and duplication testing as well as sequencing |
Gene-panel testing | Semi-targeted | Syndrome associated with several epilepsy-related genes, or syndrome not clearly related to specific gene | If several genes may be candidates for a syndrome, this option is more time-efficient than serial single-gene testing, and faster than WES and WGS | Not all commercially available tests include deletion and duplication testing, as well as sequencing Expensive |
WES | Untargeted (but analysis should include targeted examination of specific genes of interest) | Epilepsy syndrome without specific gene associations | Currently, difficult to derive copy number information from WES data | Incidental findings Expensive Coverage of specific genes not guaranteed because of limitations in capture technology |
WGS | Untargeted (but analysis should include targeted examination of specific genes or regions of interest) | Epilepsy syndrome without specific gene associations | Also enables evaluation for copy number abnormalities | Incidental findings Expensive Not yet covered by insurance |
Abbreviations: CMA, chromosomal microarray analysis; WES, whole exome sequencing; WGS, whole genome sequencing.