Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Jul 10.
Published in final edited form as: Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009 Jul 8;(3):CD001055. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001055.pub3
Methods Randomised controlled trial in Greater Burlington, Vermont, USA. 2001-2003
Participants Participants were recruited from 1 of 4 large obstetric practices. Inclusion criteria: self-reported smoking (even a puff in the last 7 days), gestational age less than 20 weeks, living within study clinic county and not planning to move until at least 6 months postpartum, English speaking, not incarcerated and not previously participating in the study or living with anyone who has previously participated in the study
182 women were eligible for the study, and 82 (45%) agreed to participate. 5 women withdrew from the study due to fetal demise or termination of pregnancy and were not included in the final analysis (I = 3, C = 2)
There was no significant difference in baseline characteristics of the groups, including pre-pregnancy cigarettes per day (I =18.7, C =18.4), health insurance (I =19, C =13), and timing of recruitment (I = 8.9, C = 9.5)
Interventions Intervention (contingent voucher): participants chose a quit date, and reported daily to the clinic for CO monitoring for 5 days, then urine cotinine monitoring twice weekly for 7 weeks, weekly for 4 weeks, and then every 2 weeks for the remainder of the pregnancy. Vouchers were given dependent on biochemical validation, beginning at US$6.25 and escalated by US$1.25 to a maximum of US$45.00. Positive test results reset voucher back to original value, but two consecutive negative tests restored value to pre-reset value Control (non-contingent voucher): Participants received voucher independent of smoking status. US$15.00 per antenatal visit and US$20.00 per postpartum visit, to result in a comparable average earnings to the contingent group
Both groups received routine advice from the clinic.
It is unclear who delivered the intervention.
The theoretical basis on the intervention is rewards and feedback
The intensity rating: I = 4, C = 4.
Outcomes Smoking cessation at 28 weeks’ gestation, 12 weeks and 24 weeks’ postpartum Reduction in mean cotinine.
Mean birthweight, gestational age, fetal growth measures (US), and proportion of NICU admissions and low birthweight babies
Notes Sample size justification. Process evaluation not reported.
Some discussion of cost implications.
Risk of bias
Item Authors’ judgement Description
Adequate sequence generation? Unclear Described as “randomisation stratified to clinics”. Details of randomisation not described
Allocation concealment? Unclear No information.
Blinding?
Women and clinical staff
No Participants and providers not blinded as receiving incentives for participation
Incomplete outcome data addressed?
All outcomes
Yes Small loss to follow up due to pregnancy termination or fetal death. Available case analysis
Free of selective reporting? Yes Detailed birth outcomes reported.
Free of detection bias? Yes Exhaled CO for 5 days (< 6 ppm) and then urine cotinine (< 80 ng/ml)