Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Jul 10.
Published in final edited form as: Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009 Jul 8;(3):CD001055. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001055.pub3
Methods Cluster-randomised trial in Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia
Participants Women attending 22 public antenatal clinics (unit of randomisation). Exclusion criteria: under 16 years of age, too sick, non-English speaking, illiterate, attendance was first visit. 194 women included in the analysis
Interventions Intensive dissemination of programme (Intervention group) included written information and feedback about programme benefits to managers, provision of programme resources, offers of visits to explain programme and provide training, sample smoking cessation policy, regular contacts to offer support, and computerised feedback on activities. Simple dissemination of programme to clinics (control group) included mail out of written information on programme benefit and resources. The cessation programme “Fresh Start for you and your baby”, developed by Windsor, based on CBT, was used Intervention intensity: I = 4, C = 4 (same intervention in both groups, only dissemination method differed)
Outcomes Biochemically validated smoking cessation at end of pregnancy, recall of smoking advice received
Participants and provider views of interventions discussed.
Notes Process evaluation showed good implementation in intervention group. No intracluster correlation or impact factor reported, so sensitivity analysis conducted using four ICCs and figures adjusting using ICC of 0.1 in outcome tables
Risk of bias
Item Authors’ judgement Description
Adequate sequence generation? Unclear Method of randomallocation not specified, but taken within strata based on clinic size and baseline smoking rates
Allocation concealment? Unclear Not specified.
Blinding?
Women and clinical staff
Unclear Educational intervention. Neither women nor providers would have been blind to the intervention
Incomplete outcome data addressed?
All outcomes
No One clinic excluded as did not report final data and some missing data for post-dissemination measures. No ITT of women dropping out of study. Only women completing study measures included in analysis
Free of selective reporting? Yes Smoking status and recall of intervention reported.
Free of detection bias? Yes Exhaled carbon monoxide >= 9.