Skip to main content
. 2014 Jul 14;20(26):8424–8448. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v20.i26.8424

Table 2.

Endoscopic ultrasound-guided drainage of pancreatic fluid collections

Ref. Design Cases Technical success Clinical success Recurrence Complications1
Binmoeller et al[8] RS 27 93% 78% 22% 52%
Pfaffenbach et al[9] PS 11 91% 82% 18% None
Giovannini et al[10] PS 35 100% 89% 9% 3%
Norton et al[11] RS 14 93% 93% 23% 14%
Vosoghi et al[12] RS 14 100% 93% 7% 7%
Enya et al[13] PS 13 100% 85% 0% None
Hookey et al[14] RS 32 96% 93% 12% 11%
Krüger et al[15] PS 35 94% 88% 12% 33%
Azar et al[16] RS 23 91% 82% 18% 4%
Antillon et al[17] PS 33 94% 87% 4% 15%
Kahaleh et al[18] PS 46 100% 93% NR 19%
Ahlawat et al[19] PS 11 100% 82% 18% 18%
Arvanitakis et al[20] RCT 46 100% 94% 11% 22%
Lopes et al[21] RS 51 94% 84% 17% 25%
Varadarajulu et al[22] PS 23 100% 95% 0% None
Lopes et al[23] PS 31 100% 94% 19% 26%
Ardengh et al[24] PS 77 94% 91% 11% 6%
Varadarajulu et al[25] RS 20 100% 95% NR None
Varadarajulu et al[26] RCT 24 100% 96% NR 4%
Varadarajulu et al[27] PS 60 95% 93% 4% 2%
Barthet et al[28] PS 28 100% 89% NR 25%
Talreja et al[29] PS 18 100% 95% 0% 44%
Park et al[30] RCT 39 95% 95% 6% 7%
Yasuda et al[31] RS 26 92% 87% 17% None
Itoi et al[32] PS 13 100% 100% 0% None
Varadarajulu et al[33] PS 10 100% 90% 0% None
Ang et al[34] PS 10 100% 100% 0% 10%
Ahn et al[35] RS 47 98% 100% 11% 11%
Jazrawi et al[36] RS 10 100% 100% 10% None
Sadik et al[37] PS 26 100% 88% 4% 15%
Will et al[38] PS 132 97% 96% 15% 29%
Seicean et al[39] PS 24 83% 79% 0% 17%
Heinzow et al[40] RS 42 88% 78% 21% 21%
Varadarajulu et al[41] PS 148 100% 99% NR 5%
Varadarajulu et al[42] RS 602 100% 69% 0% 8%
Varadarajulu et al[43] RS 20 100% 100% 5% None
Zheng et al[44] PS 14 90% 90% 0% 19%
Voermans et al[45] RCT 52 100% 82% 9% 11%
Mangiavillano et al[46] PS 21 86% 81% 14% 5%
Seewald et al[47] RS 80 97% 83% 13% 26%
Itoi et al[48] RS 15 100% 100% 0% 6%
Puri et al[49] PS 40 100% 97% 2% 7%
Fabbri et al[50] PS 20 100% 95% 5% 15%
Rasmussen et al[51] RS 22 86% 86% 18% 18%
Khashab et al[52] RS 10 100% 100% 0% None
Penn et al[53] PS 20 100% 85% 18% 15%
Weilert et al[54] PS 18 100% 78% NR 33%
Rana et al[55] RS 202 100% 100% 0% 5%
Binmoeller et al[56] RS 14 100% 79% NR 21%
Nan et al[57] RS 21 100% 100% NR 5%
Kato et al[58] RS 67 88% 83% 15% 1%
Künzli et al[59] RS 108 97% 84% 18% 20%
Siddiqui et al[60] RS 88 99% 79% 3% 30%
Rische et al[61] RS 18 100% 94% 6% 33%
Varadarajulu et al[62] RCT 20 100% 95% 0% None
Total 55 studies 1867 97% (83%-100%) 90% (69%-100%) 8% (0%-23%) 17% (0%-52%)
1

Complications include: early and late, procedural and stent related;

2

Only patients with walled-off pancreatic necrosis. RCT: Randomized controlled trial; PS: Prospective study; RS: Retrospective study; NR: Not reported.