Table 2. Efficacy of two putative bitter blockers: bitter rankings from forced-choice paired-comparison tests (mean ± SEM) and summary of post hoc analyses1.
Blocker = NaG | Bitter | Bitter+NaG | NaG | Diluent | |
Children | Urea | 3.3±0.1a | 2.5±0.1b | 2.6±0.1b | 1.6±0.1c |
Caffeine | 3.3±0.1a | 2.9±0.1a | 2.1±0.1b | 1.6±0.1c | |
Quinine | 3.5±0.1a | 2.8±0.1b | 2.0±0.1c | 1.7±0.1c | |
PROP | 3.3±0.1a | 2.9±0.1a | 2.1±0.1b | 1.7±0.1b | |
Denatonium | 3.5±0.1a | 3.1±0.1a | 1.8±0.1b | 1.6±0.1b | |
Adults | Urea | 3.6±0.1a | 2.6±0.1b | 2.3±0.1b | 1.5±0.1c |
Caffeine | 3.6±0.1a | 3.1±0.1b | 2.0±0.1c | 1.4±0.04d | |
Quinine | 3.7±0.1a | 2.8±0.1b | 2.0±0.1c | 1.5±0.1c | |
PROP | 3.3±0.1a | 3.2±0.1a | 2.0±0.1b | 1.5±0.1c | |
Denatonium | 3.8±0.04a | 3.1±0.04b | 1.8±0.1c | 1.3±0.05d | |
Blocker = MSG | Bitter | Bitter+MSG | MSG | Diluent | |
Children | Urea | 3.3±0.1a | 2.6±0.1b | 2.4±0.1b | 1.7±0.1c |
Caffeine | 3.2±0.1a | 3.1±0.1a | 2.1±0.1b | 1.6±0.1b | |
Quinine | 3.3±0.1a | 2.9±0.1a | 2.0±0.1b | 1.8±0.1b | |
PROP | 3.0±0.1a | 3.0±0.1a | 2.3±0.1b | 1.7±0.1c | |
Denatonium | 3.4±0.1a | 3.1±0.1a | 2.0±0.1b | 1.5±0.1b | |
Adults | Urea | 3.5±0.1a | 2.5±0.1b | 2.4±0.1b | 1.5±0.1c |
Caffeine | 3.5±0.1a | 3.2±0.1a | 2.0±0.1b | 1.4±0.1c | |
Quinine | 3.7±0.05a | 2.8±0.1b | 2.0±0.1c | 1.5±0.1d | |
PROP | 3.2±0.1a | 3.1±0.1a | 2.2±0.1b | 1.5±0.1c | |
Denatonium | 3.7±0.05a | 3.2±0.1b | 1.8±0.05c | 1.3±0.1c |
All Friedman statistical tests of rank tests were significant at p≤0.0001. Abbreviations: SEM, standard error of the mean. Bitter compounds—0.5 M urea; 0.008 M caffeine; 1.19×10−4 M quinine; 5.60×10−4 M PROP (propylthiouracil); 4.92×10−7 M denatonium benzoate. Putative bitter blockers—NaG, 0.3 M sodium gluconate; MSG, 0.1 M glutamate. Diluent was distilled water. Blockers were compared separately against each bitter alone, bitter + blocker, and diluent. Rankings for bitterness range from 1 (least) to 4 (most); see Table S1 for ranking procedure. Different letters indicate rankings that are statistically different from each other within each row using p<0.05 as the statistical threshold for the omnibus and post-hoc tests.