Table 3.
Clinical practice and proxy clinical practice outcomes and data collection methods
Method | Outcome assessment period/timing | Data source | Level data collected | Analysis level | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Primary outcome |
|
|
|
|
|
Appropriate post-traumatic amnesia screening (PTA) |
Chart audit (retrospective) |
2 month period post-intervention |
Hospital record |
Patient |
Patient |
Secondary outcomes | |||||
Clinical practice outcomes
|
|
|
|
|
|
PTA screening tool |
Chart audit (retrospective) |
2 month period post-intervention |
Hospital record |
Patient |
Patient |
Memory - clinical assessment |
Chart audit (retrospective) |
2 month period post-intervention |
Hospital record |
Patient |
Patient |
Computed tomography scan - clinical criteria (CT)1 |
Chart audit (retrospective) |
2 month period post-intervention |
Hospital record |
Patient |
Patient |
Provision of patient information (INFO) |
Chart audit (retrospective) |
2 month period post-intervention |
Hospital record |
Patient |
Patient |
Safe discharge based on PTA and INFO |
Chart audit (retrospective) |
2 month period post-intervention |
Hospital record |
Patient |
Patient |
Safe discharge based on PTA, CT, and INFO |
Chart audit (retrospective) |
2 month period post-intervention |
Hospital record |
Patient |
Patient |
Proxy measures of clinical practice
|
|
|
|
|
|
Self-report of adherence to recommended practice |
|
|
|
|
|
• PTA |
Staff questionnaire (1-item) |
Baseline/Endpoint |
Doctors |
Staff member |
Staff member |
|
Nurses |
||||
• CT |
Staff questionnaire (1-item) |
Baseline/Endpoint |
Doctors |
Staff member |
Staff member |
• INFO |
Staff questionnaire (1-item) |
Baseline/Endpoint |
Doctors |
Staff member |
Staff member |
|
Nurses |
||||
Behavioural simulation2 to adhere to recommended practice |
|
|
|
|
|
• PTA |
Staff questionnaire (clinical vignettes) |
Endpoint |
Doctors |
Staff member |
Staff member |
Nurses | |||||
• CT |
Staff questionnaire (clinical vignettes) |
Endpoint |
Doctors |
Staff member |
Staff member |
Nurses | |||||
• INFO |
Staff questionnaire (clinical vignettes) |
Endpoint |
Doctors |
Staff member |
Staff member |
Nurses |
1Criteria that justify a scan are: age 65 years or older; GCS <15; amnesia; suspected skull fracture; vomiting and coagulopathy (see Additional file 1). 2Clinical decision in response to individual simulated patients, for example in patient scenarios.