Table 8.
Clinical features |
Imaging |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ET and controls, age (SD) | ET | Cri | Tasks | Results ET vs HC | Data analysis | |||
Bucher et al. (1997), 1.5T | 12 ET 61.1(11.9) | 15 HC 58.2(9.8) | UE | Fin | ET (most effected arm vs rest) and HC (mimicking tremor right arm vs rest) | ↑ | Bilateral cerebellum Bilateral red nucleus |
Whole brain Pcor < 0.05 |
Cerasa et al. (2010), 1.5T | 12 ET 62.2(12.4) | 12 HC 59.8(10.7) | UE | D | Stroop task | ↑ | Left dorsolateral prefrontal, bilateral inferior parietal cortex* | Whole brain FDR Pcor < 0.05 |
Passamonti et al. (2011), 3T | 15 ET 61.6(9.3) | 15 HC 60.4(7.3) | UE | D | High vs low load verbal working memory | ↑ | Cerebellum* | Whole brain Connectivity seed cerebellum FWE Pcor < 0.05 |
Popa et al. (2013), 3T | 11 ET 51.5(11.8) | 11 HC 51.8(14.0) | UE, head, voice | D | − | ↓ | CTC pathways* | rsfMRI connectivity ROI: Cerebellum-MC vs Cerebellum-DBN 1 Hz rTMS Pcor < 0.05 |
Fang et al. (2013), 3T | 20 ET 50.3(14.2) | 20 HC 50.3(14.2) | UE, LE, head, voice | L | – | ↓ | Bilateral cerebellar lobes, bilateral thalamus (mediodorsal and ventral intermediate thalamic nucleus), insular lobe* | Regional homogeneity rsfMRI Pcor < 0.05 |
↑ | Bilateral prefrontal, parietal cortices, left primary cortex* |
Cor, multiple comparison corrected; Cri, criteria; CTC, cerebello-thalamo-cortical pathways; cor, multiple comparison corrected; D, Deuschl et al. (1998); DBN, default brain network; EMG, electromyography; ET, essential tremor; FDR, false discovery rate; Fin, Findley et al. (1993); HC, healthy controls; head, head tremor; L, Louis et al. (1998); LE, lower extremity; lSMA, left supplementary motor area; MC, motor cortex; PMA, primary motor area; PSA, primary sensory area; ReHo, regional homogeneity; ROI, region of interest; rs, resting state; rTMS, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation; UE, upper extremity; Punc, multiple comparison uncorrected; voice, voice tremor; vs, versus. *Not included in fig. 2