Table 1.
Study | Year | Country | Study Design | Inclusion Criteria |
Exclusion Criteria | LEEP (n) |
Unexposed |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Haffenden | 1993 | UK | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Birth < 24 weeks | 152 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 152 |
Blomfield | 1993 | UK | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Birth < 20 weeks | 40 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 80 |
Braet | 1994 | UK | Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Multiple gestation | 78 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 78 |
Cruickshank | 1995 | UK | Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation | 149 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 298 |
Sadler | 2004 | New Zealand |
Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation, LEEP during pregnancy |
278 | Prior dysplasia, no prior tx N=426 |
Tan | 2004 | UK | Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Age > 35 years | 119 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 119 |
Acharya | 2005 | Norway | Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Age >45 years, birth <20 weeks | 79 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 158 |
Samson | 2005 | Canada | Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation, prior PTB, indicated deliveries |
571 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N=571 |
Crane | 2006 | Canada | Prospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Multiple gestation | 75 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 144 |
Nohr | 2007 | Denmark | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Multiple gestation, indicated deliveries, stillbirth |
349 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 14,567 |
Himes | 2007 | USA | Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation, anomalies, LEEP during pregnancy |
114 | Prior dysplasia, no prior tx N= 962 |
Jakobsson | 2007 | Finland | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Age > 49 years, age < 15 years, multiple gestation |
2690 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 1,056,855 |
Ortoft | 2010 | Denmark | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Multiple gestation, indicated deliveries |
572 | No hx of dysplasia or prior tx N=72,899 |
Werner | 2010 | USA | Retrospective cohort |
1st pregnancy post-LEEP |
Multiple gestation, LEEP during pregnancy |
511 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 240,348 Prior dysplasia, no prior tx N= 842 |
Andia | 2011 | Spain | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Multiple gestation | 189 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 189 Prior dysplasia, no prior tx N= 189 |
Lima | 2011 | Portugal | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
None | 18 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 58 |
Poon | 2012 | UK | Case control | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
Multiple gestation, cerclage, anomalies, preterm PROM, contractions, progesterone, indicated deliveries |
473 | Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 25,772 |
Van Hentenryck | 2012 | Belgium | Retrospective cohort | Pregnancy post- LEEP |
None | 40 | Unk dysplasia hx, no prior tx N= 212 |
Simoens | 2012 | Belgium | Prospective cohort | Pregnancy post – EEP |
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation | 52 | No hx of dysplasia or prior tx N= 104 |
LEEP, loop electrosurgical excision procedure; hx, history; tx, treatment; PROM, premature rupture of membranes.