Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 Apr 1.
Published in final edited form as: Obstet Gynecol. 2014 Apr;123(4):752–761. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000000174

Table 1.

Characteristics of Included Studies

Study Year Country Study Design Inclusion
Criteria
Exclusion Criteria LEEP
(n)
Unexposed
Haffenden 1993 UK Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Birth < 24 weeks 152 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 152
Blomfield 1993 UK Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Birth < 20 weeks 40 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 80
Braet 1994 UK Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Multiple gestation 78 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 78
Cruickshank 1995 UK Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation 149 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 298
Sadler 2004 New
Zealand
Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation,
LEEP during pregnancy
278 Prior dysplasia, no prior tx
N=426
Tan 2004 UK Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Age > 35 years 119 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 119
Acharya 2005 Norway Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Age >45 years, birth <20 weeks 79 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 158
Samson 2005 Canada Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation,
prior PTB, indicated deliveries
571 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N=571
Crane 2006 Canada Prospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Multiple gestation 75 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 144
Nohr 2007 Denmark Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Multiple gestation, indicated
deliveries, stillbirth
349 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 14,567
Himes 2007 USA Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation,
anomalies, LEEP during pregnancy
114 Prior dysplasia, no prior tx
N= 962
Jakobsson 2007 Finland Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Age > 49 years, age < 15 years,
multiple gestation
2690 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 1,056,855
Ortoft 2010 Denmark Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Multiple gestation, indicated
deliveries
572 No hx of dysplasia or prior tx
N=72,899
Werner 2010 USA Retrospective cohort 1st pregnancy
post-LEEP
Multiple gestation, LEEP during
pregnancy
511 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 240,348
Prior dysplasia, no prior tx
N= 842
Andia 2011 Spain Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Multiple gestation 189 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 189
Prior dysplasia, no prior tx
N= 189
Lima 2011 Portugal Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
None 18 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 58
Poon 2012 UK Case control Pregnancy post-
LEEP
Multiple gestation, cerclage, anomalies, preterm PROM,
contractions, progesterone,
indicated deliveries
473 Unknown dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 25,772
Van Hentenryck 2012 Belgium Retrospective cohort Pregnancy post-
LEEP
None 40 Unk dysplasia hx, no prior tx
N= 212
Simoens 2012 Belgium Prospective cohort Pregnancy post –
EEP
Birth < 20 weeks, multiple gestation 52 No hx of dysplasia or prior tx
N= 104

LEEP, loop electrosurgical excision procedure; hx, history; tx, treatment; PROM, premature rupture of membranes.