Table 3.
All bribes, cross-section sample, 2004
(1) Tobit | (2) Tobit | (3) IV Tobit [MLE] | (4) IV Tobit [MLE] | (5) IV Tobit [MLE] | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
‘99 vote : PDIP- GOLKAR | .101** (.0346) | .108** (.0408) | .199** (.0897) | .243** (.0995) | .240** (.110) |
Ln (employ) | 2.66** (1.31) | 2.30* (1.30) | 2.68** (1.33) | 2.10 (1.30) | 2.20 (1.30) |
Ln (employ) sq. | −.166 (.142) | −.137 (.140) | −.175 (.145) | −.126 (.142) | −.136 (.142) |
Capital size: 500m-1b | 2.49** (.825) | 2.32** (.849) | 2.46** (.872) | 2.42** (.892) | 2.33** (.907) |
Capital size: 1b–5b | 4.15** (1.20) | 3.81** (1.19) | 4.21** (1.22) | 4.00** (1.21) | 3.89** (1.22) |
Capital size: 5b–20b | 3.15** (.956) | 2.60** (1.00) | 3.06** (.924) | 2.79** (.964) | 2.61** (.976) |
Capital size: over 20b | 1.06 (1.42) | .399 (1.50) | 1.02 (1.36) | .831 (1.42) | .845 (1.42) |
Dummy FDI | .936 (1.23) | .560 (1.22) | .831 (1.18) | .406 (1.19) | .449 (1.48) |
Dummy export | .278 (.897) | −.0089 (.884) | .596 (.971) | .0426 (.881) | .089 (.891) |
Dummy Chinese | 2.81** (1.12) | 2.25** (.973) | 2.61** (1.26) | 2.32** (1.14) | 2.13** (1.08) |
Controls: no vote, ind. dummy, capital rent dummy, visit cost | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Controls: lnGDPpc99, ln(no. firms01), % export01, avg. profit01 | No | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
%ΔGDPpc9904, Δratio Islamic sch0006, avg “efficiency” dist. govt. | No | Yes | No | No | Yes |
N [zeros] | 2474 [932] | 2474 [932] | 2474 [932] | 2474 [932] | 2474 [932] |
Variance σ2 [ρ]a | 11.0** (.813) | 11.0** (.804) | 11.0 [−.12] (.751) [(.11)] |
10.9 [−.16] (.739) [.12] |
10.9 [−.15] (.736) [.13] |
ρ’s are the correlation of the error terms between the main bribe equation and the equation for vote share.
Standard errors for Tobits are based on clustering. One asterisk indicates a 10% significance level and two a 5% level.