Table 2. Pairwise comparisons between replicate systems for RAS and AS separately, based on DGGE and 454 pyrosequencing data sets.
Statistical test | Analytical Method | D00 | D07 | D14 | D28 | D42 | ||||||
AS1-5 | Ra-Rb | AS1-5 | Ra-Rb | AS1-5 | Ra-Rb | AS1-5 | Ra-Rb | AS1-5 | Ra-Rb | |||
Perm. ANOVA | GUT | DGGE | 2/10 | P:0.0001 | 6/10 | P:0.0003 | 6/10 | P:0.0001 | 7/10 | P:0.0003 | 7/10 | P:0.0001 |
454 | P:0.2079 | P:0.0025 | P:0.0242 | P:0.016 | ||||||||
ANOSIM | DGGE | R:0.428 | R:0.925 | R:0.787 | R:0.772 | R:0.542 | R:0.922 | R:0.745 | R:0.596 | R:0.907 | R:0.862 | |
P:0.0005 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0001 | |||
454 | R:1 | R:1 | R:1 | R:0.846 | ||||||||
P:0.1 | P:0.002 | P:0.1 | P:0.002 | |||||||||
Perm. ANOVA | WATER | DGGE | P:0.0002 | P:0.0212 | P:0.0002 | P:0.0001 | P:0.0008 | |||||
ANOSIM | R:0.996 | R:0.972 | R:1 | R:1 | R:0.988 | |||||||
P:0.008 | P:0.008 | P:0.008 | P:0.008 | P:0.008 |
Tests were performed by sample type per sampling day, with P values for each comparison from two different statistical tests (PERMANOVA and ANOSIM). ANOSIM results are complementary to the PERMANOVA to provide information on the degree of separation between groups, suggested by R statistic. The 2/10, 6/10 & 7/10 indicate the number of significant out of the total available comparisons. D00, 07, 14, 28, 42: sampling day 0,7,14,28 & 42 respectively, AS1-5: replicate active suspension system 1 till 5, Ra & Rb: replicate recirculating system a & b. P values are based on 9999 Monte Carlo permutations.