Table 2.
Class | Reagent (support matrix) | Method | Signal Properties |
Detection Limit |
Range | Selectivity | Year | Ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Electrochemical | Bi-SPE | ASV | N/A | 0.15 ppb | 0.5 – 100 ppb | unknown | 2011 | 69 |
G-quadruplex with crystal violet | DPV | N/A | 82.2 ppt | 0.2 – 205 ppb | good | 2011 | 70 | |
1,10-phenanthroline | ASV | N/A | 82.2 ppt | N/A | nonspecific | 2011 | 72 | |
DNA/C-TiO2 NTs | ASV | TiO2 | 0.7 ppt | 2.1 ppt – 32.8 ppb | good | 2010 | 71 | |
carbon composite PVC-based membrane | ASV | Pt wire | 65.8 ppb | 0.158 – 20,548 ppm | good | 2010 | 73 | |
Nanoparticles | Au nanoparticles | Fluorescence Absorbance | Ex: 330nm Em: 600nm | 247 ppb | N/A | poor | 2012 | 74 |
Au nanoparticles and DNAzymes | DLS | Adsorption at ~540 nm | 1.3 ppt, 7.2 ppt | 2.1 – 61.1 ppt | good | 2012, 2011 | 85,86 | |
CdTe-QDs | Fluorescence | Ex: 525nm Em: 560nm (QY =0.07) | 30 ppb | 0.22–4.51 ppm | good | 2009 | 75 | |
DNAzymes | cationic polythiophene (PT) DNAzyme | Fluorescence | N/A | 0.2 ppb | 0.002 – 20 ppm | good | 2012 | 82 |
DNAzyme with graphene oxide | Fluorescence | Em: ~565 nm | 100 ppt | N/A | good | 2011 | 79 | |
Computer-Readable DNAzyme on Disc | Error Distribution of CD | N/A | 2ppb | 0.002–205 ppm | good | 2011 | 81 | |
GR-5DNAzyme | Fluorescence | N/A | 0.76 ppb | N/A | good | 2010 | 78 | |
DNAzyme in amicrofluidic device | LIF | Ex: 488 nm Em: 518 nm | 2.3 ppb | 0.020.5 – 20.5 ppm | good | 2005 | 80 | |
DNAzyme-Au-NPs | Absorbance | Abs: 522 & 700 nm | can be tuned | can be tuned | good | 2003 | 77 | |
Small Molecules | Calix-DANS3-OH (PDMS microfluidic chip) | Fluorescence | Ex: 365 nm Em: 496 nm | 42ppb | N/A | good | 2012 | 102 |
triazolo-thiadiazi (imbedded in PVC) | Fluorescence | Ex: 330 nm Em: 430 nm QY=0.039 | 4.5 ppb | 0.010.2 – 78.1 ppm | good | 2011 | 99 | |
PDA-polymer | Fluorescence | Ex: 254nm Em: 540 nm | 0.8 ppm | N/A | good | 2011 | 104 | |
LFS-1 | Fluorescence | Em: 469 nm | N/A | N/A | good | 2011 | 105 | |
L2 (immobilized on PVC) | Fluorescence | N/A | 41 ppb | 0.062 – 5137 ppm | N/A | 2010 | 106 | |
Arsenazo III (immobilized on XAD-16) | Reflectance | N/A | 10 ppb | 0.205–20.5 ppm | N/A | 2010 | 107 | |
Lead-selective ionophore (immobilzed on PVC) | Absorbance | N/A | 5 ppb | 0.007 – 10.7 ppm | N/A | 2010 | 108 | |
BODIPY-functionalized Fe3O4.SiO2 nanoparticles | Fluorescence | Ex: 326&596 Em: 456 nm (QY=0.042) | 1.5 ppb | 0 – 30 ppb | good | 2010 | 109 | |
Calix-DANS4 | Fluorescence | Ex: 365 nm | 5 ppb | N/A | N/A | 2009 | 101 | |
1,8-diaminoanthraquinone | Absorbance | Abs: 524 nm | Eye: 2–3 ppm UVvis: 21 ppb | N/A | good | 2009 | 98 | |
Imine-bridged TTF-pi-Py | Absorbance and Electrochemical | Abs: 508 nm | micromolar | N/A | Zn2+ interferes | 2009 | 110 | |
Leadglow (LG) | Fluorescence | Ex: 389 nm Em: 423 nm | 10 ppb | 1 –50 ppb | good | 2009 | 100 | |
LF1 | Fluorescence | LF1:Pb2+: Em:514 (QY=0.013) | <15 ppb | N/A | good | 2006 | 97 | |
Ketoaminocoumarin (solution) | Fluorescence | Ex: 411nm Em:491 (QY=0.35) | N/A | N/A | good | 2002 | 96 |
Selectivity: good (Mn2+, Mg2+, K+, Fe2+, Fe3+, Co2+, Cd2+, Al3+, Ag+, Zn2+, Ca2+, Ba2+, Sr2+, and Hg2+), N/A (unknown - not known or only a few metal ions tested), nonspecific.