Skip to main content
. 2014 Jul 2;111(30):E3026–E3032. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1406297111

Fig. 1.

Fig. 1.

Intraunit-cell electronic structure symmetry in the CuO2 plane. (A) Schematic of translationally invariant electronic structure pattern with opposite-sign density on Ox and Oy (d symmetry), as discussed in refs. 12, 13, and 32. The inactive Cu sites are indicated by gray circles. Inset shows elementary Cu, Ox, and Oy orbitals, on the three sublattices in the CuO2 plane; rCu sublattice contains only the Cu sites, rOx sublattice contains only the Ox sites, and rOy sublattice contains only the Oy sites. Referring to this arrangement as having “d symmetry” does not, at this stage, imply any specific relationship to the d-symmetry Cooper pairing of the superconducting state. (B) Fourier transform of the Q = 0 C4-breaking pattern of opposite-sign density on Ox and Oy in A. The Bragg peaks have the opposite sign, indicating the IUC states have d symmetry (12, 32). (C) Schematic of a d-form factor DW ρD(r)=DCos(Qxr+ϕD(r)) with the origin chosen at a Cu site and modulating only along the x axis. The colors represent the density ρD(r) at every oxygen site. Two thin lines are shown; one labeled Ox traverses parallel to Qx and passes only through oxygen sites oriented along the x axis, and the second one labeled Oy again traverses parallel to Qx but passes only through oxygen sites oriented along the y axis. The color scale demonstrates how the amplitude of the DW is exactly π out of phase along these two trajectories. (D) The real component of the Fourier transform of the pattern in C. For this d-form factor DW, the Bragg-satellite peaks at Q′ and Q′′ exhibit opposite sign. More profoundly, because they are out of phase by π, the modulations of Ox and Oy sites cancel, resulting in the disappearance of the DW modulation peaks at ±Q within the BZ (dashed box). (E) The real component of the Fourier transform of a d-form factor DW having modulations at Q = (Q,0);(0,Q) (SI Text, section 3); the DW satellites of inequivalent Bragg peaks at Q′ and Q′′ exhibit opposite sign, and the basic DW modulation peaks at Q have disappeared from within the BZ, as indicated by open circles. (F) The real component of the Fourier transform of an s′-form factor DW having modulations at Q = (Q,0);(0,Q) (SI Text, section 3); the DW satellites of inequivalent Bragg peaks at Q′ and Q′′ now cancel whereas the basic DW modulation peaks at Q are robust within the BZ.