Table 2.
Tumor Vaccine Products: Advantages and Disadvantages
Product | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|
Single peptide | Easy to produce and standardize Immune monitoring of a single antigen |
Prior identification of the single TAA Antigen-loss tumor variants |
DCs pulsed with peptide, mRNA or apoptotic bodies | Antigen presentation using both MHC class I and II molecules | Complex production Antigen-loss variants Peptide use requires prior identification of the single TAA |
Autologous whole cell tumor vaccine | No need to identify TAAs All tumor antigens likely represented and correct MHC restriction insured |
Requires patient tumor sample Complex production |
Allogeneic whole cell tumor vaccine | No need to identify TAAs Easier to produce and standardize vs. autologous product MHC mismatch may be overcome by cross priming |
Inappropriate tumor antigen presentation Correct antigens may be missing |
Modified from Rousseau et al. 2005 [16].
Abbreviations: Dendritic cell (DC); Major histocompatibility complex (MHC); Tumor associated antigen (TAA).