Table 6.
HR protein | Function(s) | Rationales for inhibiting | Challenges | Compounds being investigated |
---|---|---|---|---|
Rad51 | Catalyzes the homology search Initiates DNA strand invasion and DNA strand exchange | The heart of HR activity | Incomplete characterization of Rad51's structure Determining whether direct or indirect inhibition would be more effective Unknowns regarding its activity (e.g., what triggers its nuclear translocation) | Cell studies only: |
• RI-1 | ||||
| ||||
RPA | Damage sensor, stabilizer Recruitment site for proteins involved in DNA replication, repair, recombination, and checkpoint activation | Essential for HR to happen | Common cleft/binding site for many proteins; difficult to isolate what would inhibit just DNA repair | Purified protein studies only: |
• Compound 4 | ||||
| ||||
Proteins that inhibit HR activity indirectly † | ||||
| ||||
cAbl | Appears to be a decision maker, determining if damage is too extensive to be repaired | Inhibits Rad51's DNA strand exchange activity, which stalls HR Is activated by IR and alkylating agents A deletion or translocation on the gene promotes tumorigenesis cAbl-deficient cells are resistant to IR and other DNA-damaging agents |
Participates in many cellular processes Inhibitors of cAbl also inhibit cKIT and possibly other tyrosine kinases; not specific to HR Also interacts with DNA-PK (in NHEJ pathway) | In clinical use: |
• Imatinib (Gleevec); available to treat CML since 2001; in trials for treating other cancers | ||||
• Dasatinib | ||||
• Nilotinib (Tasigna) | ||||
• Bosutinib | ||||
| ||||
PARP1 | Surveillance/damage sensor Assesses extent of damage; determines whether to signal apoptosis Helps decondense chromatin Recruits repair proteins to the damage site Facilitates repairs |
Uses NAD+ to transfer ADP-ribose polymers onto specific acceptor proteins including itself; this modifies the protein's properties PARP1 inhibition causes accumulation of DNA damage that collapses replication forks; cancers deficient in HR cannot repair such damage Inhibitors potentiate the effects of aklylating agents, platinating agents, topoisomerase 1 poisons, IR |
Secondary mutations can correct for this repair deficiency, causing a resistance to PARPis | PARPis are available to treat familial breast cancers and other BRCA-like cancers >110 clinical trials in progress for second- and third-generation PARPis and broader use of first-generation inhibitors |
| ||||
HSP90 | Facilitates the correct folding, maturing and stabilizing of many proteins into their active form | Protects cells under stress conditions; upregulated in cancers Inhibition triggers ubiquitination Inhibition disrupts multiple pathways: blocks all major hallmarks of cancer; triggers ubiquitination; decreases Rad51 levels, thwarting HR |
Difficult to produce Inhibitory activity still being characterized; may inhibit one or more checkpoint kinases |
In Phase I and II trials: |
• 17-DMAG | ||||
• Alvespimycin (KOS-1022) | ||||
• AT13387 | ||||
• AUY922 | ||||
• CNF2024 (BIIB021) | ||||
• Debio 0932 (CUDC-305) | ||||
• DS-2248 | ||||
• Ganetespib (STA-9090) | ||||
• KW-2478 | ||||
• MPC-3100 | ||||
• PU-H71 | ||||
• Retaspimycin (IPI-504) | ||||
• SNX-5422 | ||||
• XL-888 | ||||
In Phase III trials: | ||||
• Tanespimycin (KOS-953; 17-AAG) | ||||
Other candidates are in preclinical studies |
Data on all PARP and HSP90 inhibitors in clinical trials are from [11].
No direct inhibitors of HR proteins have been found/developed yet. The proteins in this section inhibit HR activity indirectly by modulating DNAdamage response mechanisms, protein-protein interactions or other mechanisms.
CML: Chronic myelogenous leukemia; HR: Homologous recombination; IR: Ionizing radiation; NHEJ: Nonhomologous end joining.
Adapted with permission from [28].