Table 2.
Summary of influential pediatric long-acting beta agonist ( LABA) and inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) safety studies.
Study | Study design | Drug class | Pediatric only | Time period | Sample size if applicable | Major findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Allen et al. [1998] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, placebo-controlled clinical trial | ICS | Yes | 1 year | 325 | ICS-treated children grew at rates similar to placebo-treated control subjects |
Bensch et al. [2002] | Randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled clinical trial | LABA | Yes | 1 year | 518 | Incidence of hospitalizations for asthma higher in formoterol groups versus placebo group |
Bisgaard [2003] | Meta-analysis covering 8 randomized, blinded, clinical trials for pediatric patients | LABA | Yes | ≥6 weeks | 2,401 | LABA use did not protect pediatric patients from asthma exacerbations compared to patients receiving an ICS, short-acting inhaled β2 agonist (SABA), or placebo; there was a significant increase in asthma-related hospitalizations for children taking a LABA |
Castle et al. [1993] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, clinical trial | LABA | No | 16 weeks | 25,180 | Twelve asthma-related and respiratory deaths in salmeterol group versus two in salbutamol group |
Childhood Asthma Management Program Research Group [2000] | Randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled, clinical trial | ICS | Yes | 4–6 years | 1,041 | Children assigned to ICS had lower growth than those assigned to nedocromil (mast stabilizer) or placebo |
Garcia Garcia et al. [2005] | Randomized, blinded, noninferiority, clinical trial | ICS | Yes | 1 year | 994 | Children assigned to ICS had lower growth compared with those assigned an leukotriene receptor antagonist |
Guilbert et al. [2006] | Randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled, clinical trial | ICS | Yes | 2–3 years | 285 | Children assigned to ICS had lower growth than those assigned to placebo |
Guo et al. [2011] | Retrospective population-based cohort study for Medicaid patients ≤40 years old | LABA | No | 6 years | 940,449 | Relative to SABA-only use, LABA use is associated with a higher risk of hospitalization but lower risk of emergency-department visit |
Malone et al. [2005] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, active controlled, clinical trial | LABA/ICS | Yes | 12 weeks | 203 | Safety profile for LABA/ICS treatment similar to that of ICS-only treatment |
Nayak et al. [2002] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, placebo-controlled, clinical trial | ICS | Yes | 12 weeks | 353 | No difference in the incidence or nature of adverse events between ICS and placebo groups |
Nelson et al. [2006] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, placebo-controlled, observational study | LABA | No | 28 weeks | 26,355 | Rate of asthma-related deaths or life-threatening experiences was significantly higher for patients on LABA therapy compared with placebo |
Pauwels et al. [2003] | Randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled clinical trial | ICS | No | 3 years | 7,241 | 3-year growth in children was reduced in the budesonide group by 1.34 cm; reduction was greatest in the first year |
Rodrigo et al. [2009] | Meta-analysis covering 92 randomized, blinded, clinical trials | LABA/ICS | No | ≥4 weeks | 74,092 | LABA/ICS-versus-ICS studies showed that combination therapy reduced exacerbations and hospitalizations and was equivalent to ICS monotherapy in terms of life-threatening events and asthma-related deaths |
Simons [1997] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, placebo-controlled clinical trial | ICS | Yes | 1 year | 241 | Growth was lower in children taking an ICS versus those on a LABA medication or placebo |
Tal et al. [2002] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, double-dummy clinical trial | LABA/ICS | Yes | 12 weeks | 286 | Treatment groups were similar in terms of their adverse-event profile and rates of discontinuation |
von Berg et al. [1998] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, placebo-controlled clinical trial | LABA | Yes | 1 year | 426 | Exacerbation rates did not vary between salmeterol and placebo groups |
Zimmerman et al. [2004] | Randomized, blinded, parallel group, placebo-controlled clinical trial | LABA/ICS | Yes | 12 weeks | 302 | No difference in asthma exacerbations between LABA/ICS and ICS-only groups |