Table 3.
Retrospective trials included in the analysis showing the name of the author, year of publication, number of patients enrolled in the trial, the intervention that was tested and the outcome
First author | Year of publication | No of patients | Intervention and number of patients | Outcome of systemic therapy |
---|---|---|---|---|
Mitchell
[34] |
2000 |
22 resectable dediff CS |
Doxorubicin based chemotherapy + surgery |
1/5 > 90% necrosis after preoperative chemo |
5 preoperative chemotherapy and 6 postoperative, 11 no chemotherapy |
5 year OS with chemotherapy 36%, without 0% |
|||
Dickey
[35] |
2004 |
42 local or advanced dediff CS |
15 Surgery |
5 year OS and median OS: with surgery 11.8% and 6.4 months |
22 surgery and chemotherapy 5 other | ||||
With surgery and chemotherapy 4% and 8.4 months | ||||
Staals
[36] |
2006 |
102 local or advanced dediff central CS |
68 Surgery |
Median survival 18 vs 23 months (not significant) |
25 surgery + chemotherapy | ||||
9 palliative care | ||||
Cesari
[7] |
2007 |
24 local or advanced mesenchymal CS |
24 surgery of which: |
10 year OS: |
5 + RT |
Surgical remission 27% |
|||
12 + chemotherapy |
Non-surgical remission 0% |
|||
Complete surgical remission 10 year DFS: | ||||
With chemotherapy 76%, without 17% | ||||
Grimer
[37] |
2008 |
266 local and 71 advanced dediff CS |
207 Surgery |
Local disease |
90 chemotherapy |
5 year OS: |
|||
40 surgery + chemotherapy |
With chemotherapy 33%, without 25% (p = 0.11) |
|||
Advanced disease | ||||
Median OS: With chemotherapy 7 months, without 3 months (not significant) | ||||
Dantonello
[38] |
2008 |
14 local mesenchymal CS |
12 Surgery + chemotherapy |
10 year OS 64% |
2 surgery + RT | ||||
Bernstein-Molho
[39] |
2012 |
9 advanced CS |
Sirolimus + cyclophosphamide |
OR 11% |
SD 56% | ||||
PFS 15 months | ||||
Italiano
[5] |
2012 |
98 advanced CS |
Doxorubicin based chemotherapy |
OR 14% |
SD 31% | ||||
PFS 5.3 months | ||||
OS 19 months |
CS chondrosarcoma, Dediff dedifferentiated, DFS disease free survival, OR objective response, OS overall survival, PFS progression free survival, RT radiotherapy, SD stable disease.