Skip to main content
. 2014 Aug 13;9(8):e103168. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0103168

Table 3. Expressions of blood cytokines, Score of BODE, 6MWD, and Psychological field before and after treatment.

Variables Per-protocol set
BF tablet group BY granule group Placebo group P-value
n = 82 n = 89 n = 91
IL-6 (logarithm)
Before treatment 4.29±1.60 4.96±1.90 4.79±1.77 0.0912
After treatment 4.34±1.66 3.87±1.21 4.31±1.68 0.1776
IL-8 (logarithm)
Before treatment 5.18±2.11 5.79±2.30 5.69±2.35 0.1098
After treatment 5.00±2.03 4.96±1.83 4.67±1.92 0.7213
IL-10
Before treatment 48.00±117.16 73.73±223.03 269.81±1135.22 0.1668
After treatment 81.01±241.75 180.41±995.53 625.43±3620.71 0.4112
IL-17 (logarithm)
Before treatment 2.47±0.76 2.69±0.81 2.52±0.64 0.3463
After treatment 2.35±0.71 2.28±0.62 2.64±0.83 0.0219
P<0.05 for A VS C, P<0.05 for BY VS Placebo
IL-1β(logarithm)
Before treatment 3.35±1.33 3.77±1.61 3.87±1.78 0.1013
After treatment 3.52±1.65 2.96±1.09 3.43±1.67 0.0776
TGF-β1 (logarithm)
Before treatment 9.13±0.66 9.23±0.59 9.06±1.28 0.6813
After treatment 9.04±0.81 9.07±0.84 9.01±0.71 0.9174
TNF-α(logarithm)
Before treatment 2.91±0.87 3.39±1.07 3.00±1.08 0.0563
After treatment 2.94±1.06 2.86±0.88 2.93±0.92 0.8333
Cortisol
Before treatment 25.23±12.73 23.97±11.27 25.61±12.67 0.5928
After treatment 26.46±17.49 29.59±21.48 22.43±11.85 0.2123
BODE score
Before treatment 3.22±1.91 3.14±1.98 3.12±1.56 0.8635
After treatment 2.90±1.78 2.61±1.80 2.54±1.63 0.3907
6MWD score
Before treatment 401.16±123.85 394.48±121.99 396.27±130.34 0.8416
90days 403.88±115.52 416.01±124.73 412.34±94.58 0.6493
180days 414.95±117.45 424.12±123.83 422.74±103.11 0.8462
Psychological field score
Before treatment 7.63±6.16 7.71±7.13 7.54±7.47 0.994
After treatment 4.78±4.02 6.30±8.40 6.92±9.50 0.1012