Skip to main content
. 2014 Aug 14;9(8):e103235. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0103235

Table 1. Relative toxicity of spinosad to successive generations of spinosad–selected and –unselected strains of the tomato borer Tuta absoluta.

Population Generation Degrees of freedom Slope ± SE LC50 (95% CI) (µg a.i./mL) LC99 (95% CI) (µg a.i./mL) RR50 (95% CI) ?2
Unselected F1 5 1.85±0.23 0.41 (0.30–0.52) 7.37 (4.36–17.04) 1.51
Spinosad-selected F2 6 1.21±0.18 1.41 (0.882–2.14) 117.77 (42.813–703.52) 3.43 (3.25–3.61) 1.51
F3 6 1.06±0.20 13.13 (4.08–43.74) 2048.90 (270.67–0.28×107) 32.01 (32.44–32.58) 9.91
F4 5 1.14±0.26 294.15 (147.85–520.62) 3166.00 (7419.20–0.13×107) 717.14 (716.26–718.01) 2.66
F5 5 1.98±0.31 1333.67 (718.99–2109.73) 19760.00 (9020.30–0.11×106) 3256.03 (3255.62–3258.03) 5.24
F7 6 1.16±0.18 2200.41 (1051.24–3944.73) 22.09×107 (6.0×107–3.9×109) 5380.88 (5379.52–5382.24) 6.74
F12 5 1.70±0.36 3706.34 (2055.99–6152.69) 86640.00 (32808.00–0.82×106) 9030.57 (9028.39–9032.74) 1.98
F13 4 1.45±0.27 1180.48 (698.73–1756.64) 47952.00 (18525.00–0.35×106) 2880.06 (2878.68–2881.44) 0.79
F14 4 1.62±0.20 1637.63 (1240.59–2117.19) 44902.00 (23312.00–0.13×106) 3993.27 (3993.08–3993.37) 3.16
F16 4 1.47±0.19 1717.33 (998.16–2764.20) 65180.00 (21576.00–0.90×106) 4191.55 (4192.49–4192.61) 5.46
F18 5 1.08±0.19 956.66 (542.62–1537.35) 0.13×106 (38335.00–0.10×107) 2338.54 (2338.42–2338.65) 1.78
F21 4 1.86±0.23 1034.05 (664.63–1462.17) 18271.00 (8876.20–76320.00) 2526.35 (2526.20–2526.49) 4.35
F22 4 2.04±0.23 1290.22 (1017.12–1601.71) 17848.00 (11037.00–37045.00) 3150.06 (3149.90–3150.21) 1.56

All of the concentration-mortality curves followed the probit model based on the χ2 goodness-of-fit test (P>0.05).