Table 3.
Algorithm | Cohort | N | Total TB detectedc | % of TB cases detected | Total MDR detected | % of MDR cases detected | Diagnostic cost per patienta | Diagnostic cost per TB case detected | Diagnostic costs: % of total costs | Total diagnostic costs per cohort | Total treatment costs |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
‘Smear’ | Total | 10000 | 1465 | 66% | 9 | 27% | $17.42 | $119 | 25%b | $174 156 | $533 346 |
Not TB | 7780 | $15.83 | $123 131 | $187 605 | |||||||
TB | 2172 | 1434 | 66% | $22.79 | $49 507 | $315 933 | |||||
MDR-TB | 48 | 32 | 66% | 9 | 27% | $31.62 | $1518 | $29 808 | |||
‘Smear/LF-LAM’ | Total | 10000 | 1798 | 81% | 13 | 33% | $21.34 | $119 | 26%b | $213 339 | $599 940 |
Not TB | 7780 | $20.00 | $155 588 | $177 433 | |||||||
TB | 2172 | 1759 | 81% | $25.78 | $55 996 | $386 085 | |||||
MDR-TB | 48 | 39 | 81% | 13 | 33% | $36.55 | $1755 | $36 422 | |||
‘Xpert’ | Total | 10000 | 1931 | 87% | 34 | 81% | $32.81 | $170 | 33%b | $328 143 | $655 047 |
Not TB | 7780 | $31.21 | $242 850 | $158 000 | |||||||
TB | 2172 | 1890 | 87% | $37.79 | $82 077 | $423 993 | |||||
MDR-TB | 48 | 42 | 87% | 34 | 81% | $67.01 | $3216 | $73 054 | |||
‘Xpert/LF-LAM’ | Total | 10000 | 2065 | 93% | 37 | 82% | $36.68 | $177 | 35%b | $366 830 | $679 843 |
Not TB | 7780 | $35.40 | $275 398 | $154 368 | |||||||
TB | 2172 | 2020 | 93% | $40.55 | $88 072 | $450 870 | |||||
MDR-TB | 48 | 45 | 93% | 37 | 82% | $70.01 | $3360 | $74 605 |
Inclusive of costs associated with clinical evaluation, chest radiograph, CD4+ testing, and specimen transport in addition to TB diagnostic testing
When HIV/ART care is included in total costs, diagnostic costs as a percentage of total costs are 0.006, 0.006%, 0.007, and 0.008% for ‘Smear’, ‘Smear/LF-LAM’, ‘Xpert’, ‘Xpert/LF-LAM’, respectively.
Includes clinical diagnosis and empiric TB treatment, and is inclusive of repeat evaluations.