Table 2.
Reference | Country | Study settings | Population age (years) | Definition used | Duration (months) | Sample size (patients) | Prevalence rate (%) | Severe cases (%) | Preventability (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Retrospective studies | |||||||||
Briant et al. [33] | New Zealand | Medical records from 13 public hospitals | Adults and elderly of mean age 58.6 years | Unintended injury, resulting in disability and caused by healthcare management rather than the underlying disease process | 12 | 6579 | 1.99 | NR | 100* |
Gurwitz et al. [32] | USA | Medical enrollees | Elderly >65 years old | An injury resulting from the use of a drug | 12 | 30 397 | 5 | 38† | 27.6 |
Prospective and observational studies | |||||||||
Peyriere et al. [36] | France | Internal Medicine Unit A of the Saint-Eloi University Hospital, Montpellier | Adults and elderly of mean age 66.5 years (19–79 years) | An injury resulting from the use of a drug | 2 | 156 | 20.5 | NR | 57.9 |
Chan et al. [37] | Australia | Royal Hobart Hospital | Elderly patients >75 years old; mean age, 81.8 years | Ocurring if one drug caused one or more adverse manifestations or if two or more drugs contributed to one adverse manifestation | 2 | 240 | 30.4 | 15.7 | 53.4 |
Edwards et al. [34] | USA | Banner Desert Medical Center, Mesa | Adults and elderly >17 years old; mean age, 66.3 years | An injury resulting from the use of a drug | 24‡ | 62 064 | 2.4 | 4.2§ | NR |
Benkirane et al. [35] | Morocco | General Teaching Hospital, Rabat | Adult population of mean age 44.3 years (18.9–59.7 years) | When a patient is unintentionally harmed as a result of drug use, including preventable and nonpreventable events | 0.24 | 1390 | 4.2 | 2 | 13.2 |
Abbreviation is as follows: NR, not reported.
The study by Briant et al. investigated preventable adverse drug events in particular.
Considered as fatal, serious and life threatening.
The incidence rate has been estimated to be in the range of 19–29% and its mean (24%) has been considered.
Only 4.2% (63 patients) were considered severe, of whom 49 patients died.