Table 1.
Comparison of FMR1 -related ovarian phenotypes among rodent model systems
| CGGnih [33] | YAC-TG296 [34] | CGGdut [40] | Full mutation/knockout [35] | Rat [36] | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Genetic background |
C57BL/6 |
FVB/N |
C57BL/6 and FVB/n |
FVB129P2 |
Sprague–Dawley |
| Premutation repeat size |
Approximately 130 repeats (variable) |
(CGG)9AGG(CGG)9AGG(CGG)72 |
>100 repeats (variable) |
n/a |
n/a |
| Expression of WT |
FMRP expression: |
FMRP expression: |
FMRP expression: |
n/a |
FMRP expression: |
| • In GCs, LCs |
• In GCs and oocytes at all follicle stages |
• In GCs of growing follicles (20 weeks) |
• In GCs, TCs, stroma of pre-antral follicles |
||
| • In oocytes of all ages (high in primordial, primary and early pre-antral follicles) | |||||
| • Not in interstitial cells | |||||
| • LCs in older stages | |||||
| • In oocytes | |||||
| • Not in interstitial cells |
FMR1 mRNA expression: |
• In oocyte cytoplasm in primordial follicles (only observed in nucleus in a small fraction of cells) |
|||
| • In GCs and oocytes at all follicle stages | |||||
| • Higher levels in ovaries compared with brain | |||||
| • Not in stromal cells | |||||
| • Not in interstitial cells |
• Weaker in atretic cells |
||||
| • Levels increased with increasing stage of follicular development | |||||
|
FMR1 mRNA expression: | |||||
| • Pre-antral and early antral follicles had higher expression than pre-ovulatory follicles | |||||
| FMRP levels in model |
• Reduced FMRP in GCs and LCs |
No altered expression measured at 6 to 8 weeks |
43% reduced in ovaries at 40 weeks |
|
n/a |
| • At 7 months, no altered levels in any ovarian cell | |||||
| • At 7 months, abnormal distribution, higher in nucleus than cytoplasm | |||||
|
FMR1 mRNA levels in model |
• Increased at all ages in ovary |
Increased levels in ovaries |
Increased in ovaries by 4.8-fold at 40 weeks |
|
|
| • Increased in GCs and oocytes (7 months) | |||||
| Nuclear inclusions |
• One seen in 1 oocyte of 1/45 PM mice |
Not done |
None |
|
|
| • None observed in other ovarian cells | |||||
| Ubiquitination |
• Higher levels in oocytes |
Not done |
|
|
|
| • Animals with > FMRP nuclear distribution had highest number of oocytes with high concentration of ubiquitination | |||||
| Histopathology |
• Grossly normal at 4 months, but 15% smaller |
• Reduced uterine weight |
|
• Increased number of follicles by 3 weeks |
|
| • Ovarian volume did not change from 4 to 12 months; no correlation with total number of oocytes and corpus lutea (in WT, declined linearly and strong correlation) |
• At PD8 and PD25, ovary size did not differ |
||||
| • Smaller size at 9 and 16 weeks |
• Ovaries larger by 3 weeks (by 12 and 18 weeks 22% and 72% larger by mass than controls) |
||||
| • Interstitial hypertrophy and tubulostromal hypertrophy (7 to 12 months) |
• Prominent cysts consistent with corpus lutea development at 18 weeks |
||||
| • Increase in ovarian cysts (incidence, number and size) | |||||
| Pattern of follicle counts compared with WT |
• Same at 4 months |
• At PD25, same number of primordial follicles |
|
|
|
| • >4 months, fewer follicles |
• Number of mature follicles reduced at PD25 and 9 weeks |
||||
| • All subclasses of follicles were reduced | |||||
| • Size of primordial pool correlated with number of advancing subclasses |
• Reduction of less mature follicle stages but not significant |
||||
| Corpus luteum characteristics |
• Reduced |
• Reduced at 9 weeks |
|
|
|
| • Decline associated with number of advanced follicles | |||||
| Granulosa cell characteristics |
• Antral follicles had 15% fewer GCs |
• Appeared with detached GC layer |
|
|
|
| • Corona of mature follicles was partial or missing leading to premature meiotic progression | |||||
| Atresia characteristics |
• High ratio of atretic follicles to advancing follicles irrespective of estrus cycle |
• Strong positive TUNEL in follicles at PD35 to 22 weeks showing an increased number of atretic cells |
|
|
|
| • Association of atresia rate and repeat number | |||||
| Fertility characteristic |
• Not published, but unpublished work from same group supports a lower fecundity. |
• Increased sterility |
|
|
|
| • Delayed time to first pregnancy | |||||
| • Reduced number of pups per litter | |||||
| Hormone profile |
Not done |
• At 10 to 12 weeks, higher levels of 17β-E2, but similar levels at 16 and 22 weeks |
|
|
|
| • From 9 to 22 weeks, follicle-stimulating hormone higher and LH lower | |||||
| Expression of other genes | Not done | • At PD25, 8 and 14 weeks, LH receptor downregulated |
• Increased protein levels of Tsc2, Sash1 and mTOR | ||
| • Large number of LH-induced ovulation-related genes downregulated at proestrus stage in adults | |||||
| • Reduced phosphorylated Akt and phosphorylated mTOR, but total levels of Akt and mTOR were not altered | |||||
| • No alterations in other major known regulators of folliculogenesis |
GC, granulosa cell; LC, luteal cell; LH, luteinizing hormone; n/a, not applicable; PD, postnatal days; PM, premutation; WT, wild type; TC, theca cells; TUNEL, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling; Akt, also known as Protein Kinase B (PKB), is a serine/threonine-specific protein kinase; mTOR, mammalian target of rapamycin.