Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 Sep 28.
Published in final edited form as: J Control Release. 2014 Apr 18;190:15–28. doi: 10.1016/j.jconrel.2014.03.053

Table 3. Case study summary.

Advantages, disadvantages and specific contributions to drug delivery of the 7 highlighted DDS.

DDS Case Study (Target Disease) Advantages Compared to Alternatives General Disadvantages Case Study Contribution
Microparticle Depots Lupron Depot® (Cancer)
  • Longer-lasting

  • Lowers Injection Frequency

  • Potential Production Issues

  • One of the first examples of controlled peptide delivery

  • Changed the way peptide/proteins can be delivered

Nanoparticles for Cancer Treatment Doxil® (Cancer)
  • EPR Targeted

  • Long-Circulating

  • Less Side-Effects

  • Lacks Active Targeting

  • EPR Effect can be Unpredictable

  • First FDA approved intravenous cancer nanoparticle

Transdermal Devices Duragesic® (Pain Relief)
  • Extended Release

  • Patient Compliant

  • Designated Dose

  • Limited Permeability Through Skin

  • Took a relevant therapeutic and provided a means for widespread self administration

Oral Delivery Systems OROS® (Various, see Table 5)
  • Designated Dose

  • Patient Compliant

  • Limited Delivery of Peptides and Proteins

  • Unidirectional Release Led to GI Irritation and Ulcers

  • Platform technology that is still relevant and delivers new therapeutics over 30 years later

Pulmonary Delivery Systems MDI Inhalers (Asthma)
  • Designated Dose

  • Patient Compliant

  • Requires Patient Trained in Inhaler Use

Challenging to Delivery Large Molecules
  • Transformed pulmonary delivery by offering controlled, on-demand delivery

Implants Vitrasert (CMV Retinitis)
  • Lasts 5-8 Months Instead of Weekly

  • Limits Number of Injections/Procedures Done to Eye

  • Invasive Surgery for Insertion and Removal

  • Potentially Lacks Systemic Treatment

  • Limited the number of invasive procedures in favor or less-invasive, longer-lasting implants

Antibody Drug Conjugates Kadcyla® (Cancer)
  • Both Targeted and Highly Potent

  • ADCs can use already FDA approved molecules

  • New DDS and Not Yet Optimized

  • Same Issues that Face mAb

  • DDS that utilized an already FDA approved molecule (Trastuzumab) to permit the delivery of highly toxic agents