Table 2. Summary of Major Research Findings on Social Isolation From Cattan et al. (2005).
Intervention | Characteristics | Effectiveness | Possible Adverse Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|
Group peer support |
Targeted specific groups. |
Consistently demonstrates effectiveness in reducing loneliness and depression and in increasing social contact and social activity level. |
Potential to alter perceptions of existing support or to disrupt relations with family and friends. |
Allowed participant input. | |||
Conducted within an existing community organization. | |||
Many recruited from within existing neighborhoods and communities. |
|||
Often included discussions of negative emotions. |
|||
One-to-one support and service provision |
Involved indirect contact between the participant and others (e.g., through e-mail). |
Consistently ineffective at reducing loneliness and social isolation. |
Potential for embarrassment or shame in reporting that they are undervalued and isolated by their own family members. |
One-to-one interventions conducted in participants’ homes. |