Table 3.
Criteria | Criteria reported | Criteria not reported | Criteria not applicable |
---|---|---|---|
N (%) | N (%) | N | |
Recipient | 36 (80%) | 9 (20%) | 0 |
[35b, 36, 37c, 38, 40-44, 45b, 47b, 49b, 51b, 52c, 54, 55, 56b, 57b, 58, 59, 61, 63b, 64b] | [39, 46, 48, 50, 53, 60, 62c] | ||
Setting | 36 (80%) | 9 (20%) | 0 |
[36, 37c, 39, 41-44, 45b, 47b, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 53-55, 56b, 57-61, 62c, 64b] | [35b, 38, 40, 46, 48, 57, 63b] | ||
Provider delivering intervention | 43 (96%) | 2 (4%) | 0 |
[35b, 36, 37c, 38, 40-44, 45b, 46, 47b, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 53-55, 56b, 57b, 58-61, 62c, 63b, 64b] | [39, 48] | ||
Mode of delivery | 45 (100%) | 0(0%) | 0 |
[35, 36, 37c, 38-44, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 53-55, 56b, 57b, 58-61, 62c, 63b, 64b] | |||
Timing of first and last contact | 22 (49%) | 23 (51%) | 0 |
[38-40, 42, 43, 45b, 47b, 51b, 53, 56b, 57b, 59, 62, 63b, 64b] | [35b, 36, 37c, 41, 44, 46, 48, 49b, 50, 52c, 54, 55, 58, 60, 61, 62b] | ||
Total number of intended contacts | 31 (69%) | 14 (31%) | 0 |
[37c, 38, 40-44, 48, 49b, 50, 51b, 53, 55, 56b, 57b, 59-61, 62c, 63b, 64b] | [35b, 36, 39, 45b, 46, 47b, 52c, 54, 58] | ||
Total time period of intervention delivery | 27 (60%) | 18 (40%) | 0 |
[35b, 37c, 38, 40-43, 45b, 48, 53, 56b, 57b, 58-62, 63b, 64b] | [36, 39, 44, 46, 47b, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 54, 55, 62b] | ||
Frequency of contact | 33 (73%) | 12 (27%) | 0 |
[37c, 38, 40-43, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 49b, 51b, 53, 55, 56b, 57b, 59, 61, 62c, 63b, 64b] | [35b, 36, 39, 44, 50, 52c, 54, 58, 60] | ||
Approximate duration of each contact | 20 (45%) | 24 (55%) | 1 |
[37b, 38, 40, 42, 44, 49b, 50, 53, 56b, 57b, 58-61, 64b] | [35b, 36, 39, 41, 43, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 51b, 52c, 54, 55, 62c, 63b] | [37] | |
Intervention fidelity | 28 (63%) | 17 (37%) | 0 |
[38, 39, 41-43, 46, 47b, 48, 49b, 50, 51b, 56b, 57b, 58-60, 62c, 63b, 64b] | [35b, 36, 37c, 40, 44, 45b, 52c, 53-55, 61] | ||
Method of quitting advised | 11 (24%) | 34 (76%) | 0 |
[38-42, 52c, 59, 63b] | [35b, 36, 37c, 43, 44, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 49b, 50, 51b, 53-55, 56b, 57b, 58, 60, 61, 62c, 64b] | ||
Behavioural counselling approach | 13 (30%) | 30 (70%) | 2 |
[38, 40, 43, 44, 49b, 50, | [53, 62] | ||
54, 57b, 59, 63b] | [35b, 36, 37c, 39, 41, 42, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 51b, 52c, 55, 56b, 58, 60, 61, 62b, 64b] | ||
Written materials | 17 (52%) | 16 (48%) | 12 |
[36, 37b, 42, 43, 49b, 50, 51b, 52b, 53, 56b, 58, 60] | [39, 40, 45b, 46, 47b, 55, 57b, 59, 61, 63b, 64b] | [35b, 37, 38, 41, 44, 48, 52, 54, 62c] | |
NRT | 5 (83%) | 1 (17%) | 39 |
[44, 48, 56, 63b] | [51] | [35b, 36, 37c, 38-43, 45b, 46, 47b, 49b, 50, 51, 52c, 53-56, 57b, 58-61, 62c, 64b] | |
Incentives | 8 (100%) | 0 (0%) | 37 |
[45b, 47b, 62b, 64b] | [35b, 36, 37c, 38-44, 46, 48, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 53-55, 56b, 57b, 58-62, 63b] | ||
Social support | 4 (36%) | 7 (64%) | 34 |
[37b, 46, 50] | [35b, 42, 44, 51, 52b] | [36-41, 43, 45b, 47b, 48, 49b, 51-55, 56b, 57b, 58-61, 62c, 63b, 64b] | |
Process of care for women unwilling to quit | 10 (22%) | 35(78%) | 0 |
[36, 38, 40, 42, 55, 58, 62b, 63b] | [35b, 37c, 39, 41, 43, 44, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 53, 54, 56b, 57b, 59-62, 64b] | ||
Process of care for women who relapse | 2 (4%) | 43 (96%) | 0 |
[38, 55] | [35b, 36, 37c, 39-44, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 53, 54, 56b, 57b, 58-61, 62c, 63b, 64b] | ||
Skills and professional qualifications of provider delivering intervention | 31 (69%) | 14 (31%) | 0 |
[35b, 36, 37c, 38, 40-44, 49b, 50, 51b, 52c, 53-55, 57b, 58-61, 63b] | [39, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 56b, 62c, 64b] | ||
Specific training given to providers | 10 (23%) | 34 (77%) | 1 |
[38, 49b, 50, 52, 57b, 60, 64b] | [35b, 36, 37b, 39-44, 45b, 46, 47b, 48, 51b, 52b, 53-55, 56b, 58, 59, 61, 62c, 63b] | [37] |
aAs intervention arms were coded, rather than whole studies, some trials with multiple intervention arms appear in two of categories.
bDenotes two intervention arms of this study were coded in the same category.
cDenotes three intervention arms of this study were coded in the same category.
Percentage reflects the proportion of studies for criteria that are applicable.