Table 2.
LITERATURE SOURCE | METHODOLOGY | FINDINGS | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
REFERENCE | DATE | COUNTRY | DESIGN | SIZE (N) | DURATION (MONTHS) | TELEMEDICINE TECHNOLOGY | FEASIBILITY AND RELIABILITY | EVENT TIMINGa | HEALTH OUTCOMESb | COMMENTS |
Khan et al.82 | 2010 | Canada | PCC | 210 | 24 | T | Yes | ↑ | O | No difference between T and VTC |
VTC | ↑ | |||||||||
Gonzalez et al.83 | 2011 | United States | PCC | 960 | NR | CVP | Yes | ↓ | O | 38 seconds longer than bedside |
Demaerschalk et al.84 | 2012 | United States | PCC | 100 | NR | Network | Yes | NM | O | NIHSS: 8 high, 6 moderate, 1 poor agreement (ataxia) |
Allibert et al.85 | 2012 | France | RCC | 161 | 72 | VTC | Yes | NM | O | LOS shorter |
Pervez et al.86 | 2010 | United States | RR | 296 | 3/6 | T, VTC | Yes | ↑ | O | “Drip and ship” is safe/effective; spoke patients less severe |
Spokoyny et al.87 | 2014 | United States | RCT | 261 | NR | T, VTC | Yes | NM | ↑ | Telestroke evaluation of head CT scans for acute tPA assessments is reliable. |
Demaerschalk et al.88 | 2012 | United States | 2 RCTs | 276 | 3 | T, VTC | VTC better | ↑ | VTC>T | VTC higher sensitivity than phone |
Handschu et al.89 | 2008 | Germany | PCC | 151 | 12 | T, VTC | Yes | VTC↓; T↑ | ↑ | Exam times (VTC, 49.8 minutes/T, 27.2 minutes) |
Puetz et al.90 | 2012 | Germany | PCC | 536 | NR | Network | Yes | NM | ↑ | Stroke neurologists can reliably interpret CT scans. |
Müller et al.91 | 2006 | Germany | PCC/RCC | 299 | 24 | VTC | Yes | NM | ↑ | All quality indicators improved; LOS lower |
Audebert et al.92 | 2009 | Germany | NR | 267 | 3 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | O | Acceptance high and stable |
Pedragosa et al.93 | 2009 | Spain | RCC/PCC | 201 | 12 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | ↑ | Telemedicine allowed 38% (from 17%) neurologist evaluation |
Nagao et al.94 | 2012 | Australia | RR | 275 | 12 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | O | Telestroke faster, safe, reliable |
Sairanen et al.95 | 2011 | Finland | PCC | 985 | 24 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | O | On-site versus telestroke similar results |
Rudd et al.96 | 2014 | United Kingdom | RCC | 2,922 | 36 | T | Yes | T ↓ | O | In-person 65 minutes, T 73 minutes |
Bruno et al.97 | 2013 | United States | RR | 889 | 20 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | ↑ | Registration delay (median 39 minutes) |
Pedragosa et al.98 | 2012 | Spain | PCC | 119 | 24 | VTC | ↑ Endovascular treatment | ↑ | ↑ | Saved time in endovascular treatment |
Walter et al.99 | 2012 | Germany | RCT | 100 | Stopped at 100 patients | MSU | MSU feasible/reliable | ↑ | O | Timing improved |
Audebert et al.100 | 2009 | United Kingdom | PCC | 3,060 | 12/24 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | ↑ | Long-term benefit for acute stroke patients |
Theiss et al.101 | 2013 | Germany | LS | 1,152 | 48 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | ↑ | Increased teleconsultations and 45% increase in protocol conformity |
Switzer et al.102 | 2013 | United States | PCC | 1,112 | 60 | VTC | Yes | ↑ | ↑ | Spoke hospitals more effectively used |
Arrows indicate direction of change: faster or increased use (↑) or slower or decreased use (↓).
Arrows indicate direction of change: improved (↑) or declined (↓).
CT, computed tomography; CVP, cellular videophone; LS, longitudinal study; MSU, mobile stroke unit with computed tomography scanner; NIHSS, National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale; NM, not measured; NR, nonrandomized; O, neutral outcome; PCC, prospective case control; RCC, retrospective case control; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RR, retrospective review; T, telephone; t-PA, tissue plasminogen activator; VTC, video teleconference.