Table 7. Summary of Campylobacter isolation and genotyping protocols.
Recovery steps (%, 95 studies) | Types | # of studies |
Farm-collected broiler samples (73.6%) | droppings: fecal, caecal, fecal/caecal swabs | 53 |
cloacal swabs | 13 | |
boot socks/overshoe | 3 | |
sand sample | 1 | |
other farm-collected but non-broiler samples | (8) | |
Abattoir level and/or laboratory collected broiler samples (45.2%) | caecal content/caecal contents swab | 30 |
cloacal swabs | 11 | |
intestinal pool | 2 | |
Combined with above samples: feathers, neck skin, bile | (4) | |
Used transport media (25.2%) | Cary Blair | 7 |
Phosphate Buffered Saline | 5 | |
Maximum Recovery Diluent | 4 | |
Amies Charcoal | 4 | |
Buffered Peptone Water | 3 | |
Used enrichment media to transport specimen | (10) | |
Incorporated enrichment step (75.7%) | Preston | 29 |
Bolton | 10 | |
Campylobacter Selective Enrichment | 10 | |
Exeter | 8 | |
Hunt's | 5 | |
Less commonly used (1–3 studies): Modified/Double Strength Enrichment, Tryptic Soy Broth, Supplemented Nutrient Broth (5% horse blood), Brucella, THAL Campy | 10 | |
Culture plating, raw and enriched samples (95.7%) | mCCDA, charcoal- based | 30 |
CCDA, charcoal- based | 12 | |
Campy-Cefex Agar, charcoal- based | 10 | |
Preston, charcoal- based | 10 | |
Campylobacter Selective Agar, blood-free | 7 | |
Campylobacter Selective Agar, blood-based | 6 | |
Less commonly used (1–4 studies): Virion, Karmali, Butzler, CAT agar, Brucella, Mueller Hinton with Preston Agar, Campy-FDA | 16 | |
Direct molecular detection, raw samples or enriched samples (4.2%) | PCR | 4 |
Antimicrobial sensitivity testing (3.1%) | Agar dilution | 1 |
E-test | 1 | |
Unknown | 1 | |
Speciation (81.0%) | PCR | 41 |
Biotyping and serotyping | 24 | |
PCR combined with biotyping and serotyping | 12 | |
Genotyping (molecular linkage) (38.9%)¥ | ||
1 method | flaA (sequencing or PCR-RFLP) | 5 |
RAPD | 5 | |
PFGE | 4 | |
Less frequently used: AFLP, MLST, ribotyping, sequencing of other genes | 4 | |
2 methods | flaA+PFGE | 8 |
flaA+MLST | 4 | |
Less frequently used: flaA+ribotyping, PFGE+RAPD, flaA/flaB+23S rRNA spacer) | 3 | |
3 methods | flaA+PFGE+AFLP | 2 |
flaA+PFGE+MLST | 1 |
some studies may have also collected samples on-farm (21 studies collected at the farm and abattoir).
Genotyping to link broiler, animal and environmental type sample matrices; methods were also used for nomenclature/arbitrary genotype assignment.
( ) not counted, mCCDA-modified charcoal cefoperazone deoxycholate agar, PCR-Polymerase Chain Reaction, flaA-flagellin A, RAPD- Randomly Amplified Polymorphic DNA, PFGE-Pulsed Field Gel Electrophoresis, AFLP-Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism. MLST – Multi-locus Sequence Typing, REA-Restriction Endonuclease Analysis.