| 1 | Heads with 5–10 florets; with only rather short involucral bracts at base; corollas 5–6 mm long; leaf blades with crenate margins | 2 |
| – | Heads with 20–40 florets; with elongate filiform bracts at base; corollas 7–11 mm long; leaf blades with serrate margins | 3 |
| 2 | Undersurfaces of leaves and branches of inflorescence with short hispidulous pubescence; heads with ca. 10 florets | Jeffreycia hildebrandtii |
| – | Undersurfaces of leaves and branches of inflorescence with long hairs forming tomentum; heads with ca. 5 florets | Jeffreycia zeylanica |
| 3 | Corollas with cluster of long stiff hairs at tips of lobes; leaf blades usually ovate with margins closely serrate; with small bracteoles in the inflorescences | Jeffreycia zanzibarensis |
| – | Corollas lacking cluster of long hairs at tips of lobes; leaf blades oblong or elliptical; with remotely serrate margins; inflorescences with large foliiform primary bracteoles | 4 |
| 4 | Peduncles with appressed stiff hairs; leaf blades shortly pubescent below; inner involucral bracts to ca. 8 mm long | Jeffreycia amaniensis |
| – | Peduncles with mostly spreading, crisped hairs; leaf blades crispate pubescent below, somewhat obscurely pubescent on lamina surface; inner involucral bracts ca. 6 mm long | Jeffreycia usambarensis |