Table 5.
Review of studies investigating the effects of phytochemicals on postprandial glucose and insulin
| Study | Subjects | Treatment | Compound | Delayed response in early phase for glucose or insulin? | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cao et al.( 36 ) | Eight healthy elderly women | 240 g strawberries, 294 g spinach, 300 ml red wine or 1250 mg vitamin C v. matched control | Various including anthocyanins (strawberries) | No | N/A |
| Johnston et al.( 7 ) | Nine healthy adults | 400 ml clear or cloudy apple juice v. CHO-matched control | Chlorogenic acid | Yes (glucose) at 15, 30 min (clear) and 15 min (cloudy) | P < 0·05 |
| Kay & Holub( 37 ) | Eight healthy men | 100 g freeze-dried wild blueberry powder in 500 ml water + high-fat meal v. matched placebo control | Anthocyanins | No | N/A |
| Bryans et al.( 38 ) | Sixteen healthy adults; 4 m, 12 f | 1 or 3 g black tea + 75 g glucose in 150 ml water v. CHO-matched control | Tea polyphenols: flavan-3-ols, catechins | No. Late-phase reduction in glucose | N/A |
| Wilson et al.( 39 ) | 187 healthy adults | High- or low-energy 240 ml cranberry juice + 80 mg vitamin C v. matched controls | Proanthocyanidins | Yes (glucose) at 30 min Yes (insulin) up to 60 min |
No |
| Hlebowicz et al.( 40 ) | Fifteen healthy adults; 9 m, 6 f | 300 g rice pudding + 1 or 3 g cinnamon | Methyl hydroxychalcone | Yes (both) up to 60 min | No (glucose) Yes (insulin) |
| Josic et al.( 41 ) | Fourteen healthy adults; 7 m, 7 f | 300 ml green tea together with white bread and sliced turkey v. CHO-matched control | Flavan-3-ols, catechins | Yes (glucose) up to 60 min | No |
| Lehtonen et al.( 42 ) | Ten healthy men | Sea buckthorn crushed berries + yogurt + 50 g glucose v. matched control | Flavonols | Yes (insulin) at 30 min | P < 0·05 |
| Törrönen et al.( 33 ) | Twelve healthy adults; 1 m, 11 f | 150 g berry purée (blackcurrants, cranberries, strawberries, bilberries) + 35 g sucrose (800 mg total polyphenols) v. sucrose + CHO-matched control | Anthocyanins | Yes (glucose) at 15 and 30 min | P < 0·05 (15 min), P < 0·01 (30 min) |
| Clegg et al.( 43 ) | Twelve healthy adults; 3 m, 9 f | 100 g blueberries or raspberries in a pancake meal v. CHO-matched control and glucose | Anthocyanins | No | N/A |
| Wootton-Beard & Ryan( 45 ) | Seventeen healthy adults; 7 m, 10 f | 70 ml beetroot juice + white bread v. CHO-matched control | Betalains | Yes (insulin) at 15 min | P < 0·05 |
| Törrönen et al.( 32 ) | Fourteen healthy adults; 3 m, 11 f | 300 ml blackcurrant juice or blackcurrant juice fortified with crowberry powder (mainly anthocyanins 89 mg/100 g v. 178 mg per 100 g) | Anthocyanins | Yes (glucose) at 30 min Yes (insulin) up to 45 min |
No |
| Törrönen et al.( 34 ) | Fifteen healthy adults | 150 g berry purée + 35 g sucrose v. sucrose + CHO-matched control | Anthocyanins | Yes (glucose) up to 45 min Yes (insulin) at 15 min |
P < 0·05 (15 min), P < 0·01 (15 min) |
| Törrönen et al.( 35 ) | Twenty healthy women | 150 g blackcurrant and lingonberry purée or nectar + 35 g sucrose v. CHO-matched control | Anthocyanins | Yes (glucose) up to 30 min Yes (insulin) up to 30 min |
No |
| Linderborg et al.( 44 ) | Ten healthy men | 40 g lingonberry powder in yoghurt + 50 g glucose v. CHO-matched control – lingonberry | Flavonol glycosides | Yes (glucose) same as berries Yes (insulin) up to 60 min |
No No |
N/A, not applicable; CHO, carbohydrate; m, male; f, female.