Table 5.
Overview of Published SILS Colectomy Series Including >20 Patients
| Series | Case Series Comparative | No. Cases | Benign/Malignancy/Mixed | Right-Sided/Left-Sided/Mixed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Champagne et al11 | Comparative | 147 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Geisler and Garrett12 | Case series | 63 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Ramos-Valadez et al13 | Comparative | 20 | Mixed | Left |
| Gajoux et al14 | Comparative | 22 | Benign | Mixed |
| Chew et al15 | Case series | 28 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Champagne et al16 | Comparative | 29 | Mixed | Mixed |
| McNally et al17 | Comparative | 27 | Malignancy | Mixed |
| Katsuno et al18 | Case series | 31 | Malignancy | Mixed |
| Papaconstantinou et al19 | Comparative | 29 | Mixed | Right |
| Lee et al20 | Comparative | 42 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Van den Boezem and Sietses21 | Case series | 50 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Ross et al22 | Case series | 38 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Boni et al23 | Case series | 36 | Mixed | Right |
| Ramoz-Valadez et al24 | Case series | 35 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Kwag et al25 | Comparative | 24 | Malignancy | Left |
| Lu et al26 | Comparative | 27 | Malignancy | Mixed |
| Fujii et al27 | Comparative | 23 | Malignancy | Mixed |
| Vestweber et al28 | Case series | 224 | Mixed | Mixed |
| Keshava et al29 | Case series | 22 | Mixed | Right |
| Current series | Comparative | 20 | Benign | Left |
Most published series are either not comparative or include different types of resections or different types of colonic disease, creating significant heterogeneity.