Skip to main content
. 2014 Sep 5;9(9):e106419. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0106419

Table 1. Photosynthesis-irradiance (P-E) curve parameters for gorgonian species.

Gorgonian species One-way ANOVA
P. anceps (9) E. tourneforti (8) P. porosa (6) P. wagenaari (6) MS F3, 25 p 1-β
gross P cm−2 2.28ac±0.61 1.66a±0.48 4.32b±1.05 3.30bc±1.07 0.22 10.47 <0.001
net P cm−2 1.49a±0.44 1.15a±0.43 3.13b±0.89 2.17a±0.70 0.24 8.59 <0.001
R cm−2 −0.79a±0.25 −0.51b±0.09 −1.19c±0.25 −1.12ac±0.38 0.19 12.12 <0.001
gross P µg−1 chl a 1.04a±0.39 0.71a±0.18 0.32b±0.08 0.15c±0.03 0.99 52.60 <0.001
net P µg−1 chl a 0.68a±0.25 0.48a±0.12 0.23b±0.05 0.10c±0.02 1.00 46.70 <0.001
gross P cell−1 *10−7 18.29a±7.35 5.27bc±1.95 8.28b±2.52 3.98c±0.70 0.50 27.46 <0.001
net P cell−1 *10−7 12.04a±5.14 3.57bc±1.23 5.95b±1.84 2.57c±0.40 0.44 22.90 <0.001
α *10−3 (P µg−1 chl a) 2.51a±1.25 1.26b±0.57 0.53c±0.22 0.32c±0.10 1.11 29.36 <0.001
24 h gross P/R 0.88±0.21 0.78±0.23 0.93±0.16 0.83±0.18 0.03 0.78 0.516 0.22

Sample sizes for each gorgonian species are given in parentheses next to the species name (see Figure 1 legend for full genus names). P and R represent photosynthetic and respiration in µmol O2 hr−1 rates at 1800 µmol quanta m−2 s−1, respectively. α represents the initial slope of the P-E curve. Table cells contain the sample mean ± standard deviation. The mean square (MS), F statistics (F), and significance value (p) are from a one-way ANOVA using gorgonian species as a factor. All variables were transformed prior to conducting ANOVA. Means with different superscript letters are statistically different (α = 0.05). Power (1- β) is shown for non-significant results.