Table 4.
Ref | Patient | Hydration Inducement | Hydration Measures | Hydration Status | Vocal Function Measures | Main Results | Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Franca & Simpson (2009) (47) |
19 F 18–35 yr healthy |
Method
Timing 14 hr fast prior to testing 1l water in 20 min Test 90mins post ingestion |
Method Patient report intake of tobacco, caffeine, alcohol & medications Timing Initial recruitment |
Pre Not measured Post Not measured |
Measures Acoustics jitter & shimmer Timing Pre ✘ Post ✓ Initial Ax in dehydrated state post fast |
Improved jitter & shimmer in rehydrated condition, but not for all participants | Hydration has a positive impact on voice Results may be applied in prevention, counseling & treatment of voice disorders for individuals & employers |
Selby & Wilson (n.d.) (56) |
8 M 18–31 yr healthy |
Method All patients abstain from alcohol & caffeinated drinks. Testing at 20°C no air conditioning
Timing 1 day prior abstinence from alcohol & caffeine Dehydration - abstain fluid from 4pm & food from 6pm day prior to testing (~18hrs) Rehydration -ingest 20min period, testing 1hr post |
Method Patient report intake of alcohol, caffeine, & water Bioelectric impedance Timing Initial recruitment Day of testing |
Pre Patient water intake .25–2l/day 50% often thirsty Impedance data not reported inconsistent& unable to track small changes in TBW Post Not measured |
Measures Laryngograph Lx imaging Acoustics jitter, Fo mode, range, irregularity Timing Pre ✘ Post ✓ Initial Ax in dehydrated state post abstinence |
Lx imaging 1/8 patients excluded due to sulcus vocalis No diff. between smokers & non-smokers Acoustics Sig. ↑ modal Fo in conversation post rehydration |
Hydration status does not have a marked influence on Fo mode, range & regularity |
Fujita et al. (2004) (3) |
6 M 28–36 yr healthy PVU Working in low humidity |
Method Remain in workplace environment (except transit) & abstain from systemic medications, coffee, alcoholic drinks & diet products
Timing Unknown general abstinence period, no fluid 4hrs prior to testing Fluid ingestion immediately following initial Ax Saline inhalation 10mins |
Method Not measured Timing Not measured |
Pre Not measured Post Not measured |
Measures Lx imaging Videokymography quotient open phase time/closed phase time dB & Hz Timing Pre ✘ Post ✓ Initial Ax in dehydrated state post abstinence |
No statistical analysis completed on results ↓ open phase time/closed phase time post hydration in 80% of patient, but ↑ in remaining 20% patient 5/6 patient presented with affections of the VF mucosa After hydration ↓ appearance of viscosity of mucus & bright VFs ↑ amplitude of VF mucosa wave vibration |
Videokymography is an objective method of Ax to determine abnormalities of VF mucosa pre- & post- hydration Reduced quotient open phase time/closed phase time following hydration |