Table 1.
Theme: | Need expressed: | Illustrative quote: |
---|---|---|
Needs for changing practice | More focus on pre-test and post-test counseling | “[What currently is missing is] good preparation for people having diagnostic tests but who are unprepared for the result (often tests offered by non-genetic specialists). More time [is needed] for psychological care after testing.” (#10 Clinical Geneticist) |
New division of responsibilities | “[A weak link in current genetic services] may be the understanding (by the geneticists) that times are changing and there should be a new way of dividing the work: an increasing role for other specialists and maybe only diagnostics/counselling of the rare diseases left as the special goal for only the clinical geneticists.” (#20 Clinical geneticist)” | |
Close collaboration and communication between geneticists and non-geneticists | “I think there needs to be development of [professional] teams around the different human disorders, and a clinical geneticists should be represented in such teams.” (#12 Clinical Geneticist) | |
Needs for changing culture | Attention for genetics in mainstream medicine | “The main problem is that other health care specialists (with few exceptions) do not recognize the influence of genetics in their field. Maybe publishing more genetics related articles in [more general] medicine journals would [lead to] more attention.” (#8 Clinical Geneticist) “[What is missing is] greater awareness of genetic risk in wider health system (outside genetics, especially in primary care).” (#10 Clinical Geneticist) |
Needs for changing structure | Statutory registration of staff trained in genetics | “Statutory registration of genetic counsellors and technical staff [is missing and] would provide quality assurance of the professional standards of these members of the workforce” (#5 Clinical Geneticist) |
Education for non-geneticists | [In order to make developments within genetic services meaningful there needs to be] better education for non-geneticists in genetic testing in their discipline.” (#7 Clinical Geneticist) | |
Availability of essential staff and equipment | “Staff and finance [are] needed. [There currently is] poor secretarial support, not enough facility for follow up of families needing screening etc. [and there is a] need for better genetic registers” (#7 Clinical Geneticist) | |
Existence of guidelines/protocols | “[An example of good practice is the availability of ] agreed protocols for offering predictive/presymptomatic testing.” (#10 Clinical Geneticist) “What could be improved are the protocols outside clinical genetics.” (#3 Researcher in Health Sciences) |
|
Legal structures | “Perhaps some policy statement [is needed] saying that if you offer genetic tests you must also be able to offer genetic counselling.” (#12 Clinical Geneticist) | |
Financial structures | “[There currently is a] lack of reimbursement of counselling and support activities by non-medical professionals” (#2 Researcher in Psychology) “[What is missing is] reimbursement for non-diagnostic tests (carrier, predictive/pre-symptomatic).” (#14 Clinical Geneticist) “[Good aspects of current genetic services include] […] reimbursement for genetic testing in patients under obligatory health care [the basic health care package], if testing meets established criteria of "medical indication".” (#6 Clinical Geneticist) |