Table 2.
Overview of treatment and comparison interventions in included studies
| Included study | Intervention | Comparison | Type of pain | Outcome measure interval1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adorjàn-Schaumann 1999 | OMT | Sham MT | Chronic | 75 days |
| Andersson 1999 | OMT | UC | Acute + Chronic | 12 weeks |
| Chown 20083 | OMT | Physiotherapy | Chronic | 6 weeks |
| Cruser 2012 | OMT | UC | Acute | 4 weeks |
| Gibson 1985 | OMT | Sham SWD | Acute + Chronic4 | 2, 4, 12 weeks |
| Gibson 1985a2 | OMT | SWD | Acute + Chronic4 | 2, 4, 12 weeks |
| Gundermann 2013 | OMT | Untreated | NS, Pregnancy | 6 weeks |
| Heinze 2006 | OMT + PT + Heat | PT + Heat | Acute + Chronic | 12 weeks |
| Licciardone 2003 | OMT | Untreated | Chronic | 30, 90, 180 days |
| Licciardone 2003a2 | OMT | Sham MT | Chronic | 30, 90, 180 days |
| Licciardone 2009 | OMT + UOBC | UOBC | NS, Pregnancy | 9 weeks |
| Licciardone 20092 | OMT + UOBC | UOBC + SUT | NS, Pregnancy | 9 weeks |
| Licciardone 2013 | OMT | Sham OMT | Chronic | 12 weeks |
| Mandara 2008 | OMT | Sham MT | Chronic | 6 weeks |
| Peters 2006 | OMT | Untreated | NS, Pregnancy | 5 weeks |
| Recknagel 2007 | OMT | Untreated | Chronic, PP | 8 weeks |
| Schwerla 2012 | OMT | Untreated | Chronic, PP | 8 weeks |
| Vismara 2012 | OMT + SE | SE | Chronic | 2 weeks |
1Bolded time interval included in the analysis of the current review.
2Second comparison in this published study.
3The second comparison in this study (group exercise) was not considered because of a dropout rate of 60%.
4Low back pain period from 2 weeks to 30 weeks.
Abbreviations: MT Manipulative treatment, NS Not specified, OMT Osteopathic manipulative treatment, PP Postpartum, PT Physical therapy, SE Specific exercises, SUT Sham ultrasound treatment, SWD Short-wave diathermy, UC Usual care, UOBC Usual obstetric care.