Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Sep 11.
Published in final edited form as: Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012 Mar 14;3:CD004233. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004233.pub3
Analgesia Rescue medication
Study ID Treatment PI or PR Number with 50% PR PGE: very good or excellent Median time to use (hr) Number using
Malmstrom 1999
  1. cele 200 mg, n = 91

  2. rofe 50 mg, n = 90

  3. ibu 400 mg,n = 46

  4. placebo, n = 45

TOTPAR 6:
  • (1)

    9.55

  • (4)

    3.07

  • (1)

    38/91>

  • (4)

    2/45

At 8 hrs:
  • (1)

    26/91

  • (4)

    3/45

  • (1)

    5.1

  • (4)

    1.5

In 24 hrs:
  • (1)

    71/91

  • (4)

    41/45

Gimbel 2001
  1. cele 200 mg, n = 141

  2. hydrocod/paracet 10/1000 mg, n = 136

  3. placebo, n = 141

SPID 6:
  • (1)

    4.38

  • (3)

    2.51

  • (1)

    55/141

  • (3)

    30/141

No data
  • (1)

    > 8

  • (3)

    3.9

At 8 hrs:
  • (1)

    62/141

  • (3)

    90/141

Malmstrom 2002
  1. cele 400 mg, n = 151

  2. cele 200 mg, n = 90

  3. rofe 50 mg, n = 150

  4. ibu 400 mg, n = 45

  5. placebo, n = 45

TOTPAR 6:
  • (1)

    10.98

  • (2)

    8.4

  • (5)

    1.04

  • (1)

    74/151

  • (2)

    32/90

  • (5)

    0/45

At 8 hrs:
  • (1)

    62/151

  • (2)

    31/90

  • (5)

    1/45


Pts did not report - assume poor response
  • (1)

    10.6

  • (2)

    6.8

  • (5)

    1.6

At 24 hrs:
  • (1)

    99/151

  • (2)

    62/90

  • (5)

    44/45

Kellstein 2004
  1. cele 200 mg, n = 101

  2. lumira 400 mg, n = 101

  3. rofe 50 mg, n = 102

  4. placebo, n = 51

TOTPAR 6:
  • (1)

    6.13

  • (4)

    1.4

  • (1)

    23/101

  • (4)

    0/51

No usable data
  • (1)

    2.0

  • (4)

    1.3

14.9% of whole group
Moberly 2007
  1. cele 400 mg, n= 51

  2. placebo, n = 52

Also tested: CS-706 at 10, 50, 100, 200 mg
TOTPAR 4:
  • (1)

    7.2

  • (2)

    2.4

  • (1)

    25/51

  • (2)

    4/51

At 24 hrs:
  • (1)

    49%

  • (2)

    14%

  • (1)

    > 12

  • (2)

    1.67

At 6 hrs:
  • (1)

    12/51

  • (2)

    41/51

Doyle 2002
  1. cele 200 mg, n = 74

  2. ibu liquigel 400 mg, n = 74

  3. placebo, n = 26

No usable data No data No usable data
  • (1)

    > 12

  • (3)

    2.0

At 12 hrs:
  • (1)

    30/74

  • (3)

    21/26

Cheung 2007
  1. cele 400 mg, n = 57

  2. ibu 400 mg, n = 57

  3. placebo, n = 57

TOTPAR 6:
  • (1)

    13.4

  • (3)

    3.7

  • (1)

    36/57

  • (3)

    5/57

No data
  • (1)

    > 24

  • (3)

    1.85

At 24 hrs:
  • (1)

    26/57

  • (3)

    49/57

Fricke 2008
  1. cele 400 mg, n = 156

  2. lumira 400 mg, n = 156

  3. placebo, n = 52

TOTPAR 6:
  • (1)

    7.78

  • (3)

    1.76

  • (1)

    49/156

  • (3)

    0/52

No usable data
  • (1)

    3.8

  • (3)

    1.3

At 24 hrs:
  • (1)

    103/156

  • (3)

    47/52

cele - celecoxib; CS-706 - experimental compound; hydrocod/paracet - hydrocodone/paracetamol; ibu - ibuprofen; lumira - lumira-coxib; pts - participants; rofe - rofecoxib