Skip to main content
NIHPA Author Manuscripts logoLink to NIHPA Author Manuscripts
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Sep 15.
Published in final edited form as: Am J Sports Med. 2013 Aug 8;42(2):492–499. doi: 10.1177/0363546513497566

Autograft Versus Nonirradiated Allograft Tissue for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

A Systematic Review

Michael W Mariscalco *, Robert A Magnussen *, Divyesh Mehta *, Timothy E Hewett *, David C Flanigan *, Christopher C Kaeding *,†
PMCID: PMC4163684  NIHMSID: NIHMS623538  PMID: 23928319

Abstract

Background

An autograft has traditionally been the gold standard for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR), but the use of allograft tissue has increased in recent years. While numerous studies have demonstrated that irradiated allografts are associated with increased failure rates, some report excellent results after ACLR with nonirradiated allografts. The purpose of this systematic review was to determine whether the use of nonirradiated allograft tissue is associated with poorer outcomes when compared with autografts.

Hypothesis

Patients undergoing ACLR with autografts versus nonirradiated allografts will demonstrate no significant differences in graft failure risk, laxity on postoperative physical examination, or differences in patient-oriented outcome scores.

Study Design

Systematic review.

Methods

A systematic review was performed to identify prospective or retrospective comparative studies (evidence level 1, 2, or 3) of autografts versus nonirradiated allografts for ACLR. Outcome data included graft failure based on clinical findings and instrumented laxity, postoperative laxity on physical examination, and patient-reported outcome scores. Studies were excluded if they did not specify whether the allograft had been irradiated. Quality assessment and data extraction were performed by 2 examiners.

Results

Nine studies comparing autografts and nonirradiated allografts were included. Six of the 9 studies compared bone– patellar tendon–bone (BPTB) autografts with BPTB allografts. Two studies compared hamstring tendon autografts to hamstring tendon allografts, and 1 study compared hamstring tendon autografts to tibialis anterior allografts. The mean patient age in 7 of 9 studies ranged from 24.5 to 32 years, with 1 study including only patients older than 40 years and another not reporting patient age. The mean follow-up duration was 24 to 94 months. Six of 9 studies reported clinical graft failure rates, 8 of 9 reported postoperative instrumented laxity measurements, 7 of 9 reported postoperative physical examination findings, and all studies reported patient-reported outcome scores. This review demonstrated no statistically significant difference between autografts and nonir-radiated allografts in any outcome measure.

Conclusion

No significant differences were found in graft failure rate, postoperative laxity, or patient-reported outcome scores when comparing ACLR with autografts to nonirradiated allografts in this systematic review. These findings apply to patients in their late 20s and early 30s. Caution is advised when considering extrapolation of these findings to younger, more active cohorts.

Keywords: autograft, allograft, ACL, radiation


Surgical reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries is recommended to restore knee stability and allow patients to return to cutting- and pivoting-type sports. There are many autograft and allograft options for reconstruction, and the decision of which graft type to use is typically based on surgeon and patient preference, patient age, activity level, and desired return to sport. Autografts have traditionally been the gold standard, with the bone–patellar tendon–bone (BPTB) and quadrupled hamstring tendon used most commonly.24,28 Allograft use has increased over the past decade mainly because of the avoidance of donor site morbidity, less postoperative pain, and faster operating room time.27,31 Disadvantages of allograft use include possible immunogenicity, delayed graft incorporation, and risk of disease transmission.1,12,15

Numerous studies have demonstrated the deleterious effects that irradiation has on the biomechanical properties and failure rates of ACL allografts.8,34,36 A recent meta-analysis by Prodromos et al33 demonstrated that irradiated allografts have an abnormal stability rate that is 2.5 times that of nonirradiated allografts. Borchers et al4 showed that the odds of failure after ACL reconstruction with an irradiated allograft were 5.6 times those after reconstruction with an autograft.

Three previous systematic reviews have compared the outcomes of ACL reconstruction using autografts versus allografts.5,10,18 These systematic reviews have varied in terms of their level of evidence, included graft types, and outcomes of interest. A common limitation of each review, however, is the inclusion of irradiated grafts in the allo-graft group. The purpose of the current systematic review was to determine whether the use of nonirradiated allo-graft tissue is associated with increased graft failure rates, postoperative laxity on physical examination, and/or poorer patient-reported outcome scores. We hypothesized that ACL reconstruction with nonirradiated allograft tissue was not associated with (1) an increased odds of graft failure as determined clinically or through instrumented laxity testing, (2) increased laxity on postoperative physical examination, or (3) decreased patient-reported outcome scores relative to ACL reconstruction with autograft tissue.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eligibility Criteria

All English-language prospective or retrospective comparative studies (evidence level 1, 2, or 3) comparing outcomes of primary ACL reconstruction with autograft tissue versus nonirradiated allograft tissue were eligible for inclusion in this review. Studies were excluded if it was not clearly stated whether the allograft had been irradiated. Patients of all ages were included. Each study was required to have a minimum of 15 patients in each group and a mean follow-up of at least 2 years. Outcome data including clinical or instrumented failure rates or patient-reported outcome scores were required for inclusion.

Literature Search and Study Selection

Literature review included a search of Scopus, Embase, CINAHL, and Cochrane Collaboration systematic reviews through October 12, 2012. Two independent reviewers (M.W.M. and D.M.) separately completed the search. Search terms included “autograft,” “allograft,” and “anterior cruciate ligament.” This search yielded a total of 649 studies across all databases. After applying a filter to include only human, English-language, and comparative autograft and allograft studies, 114 studies remained. The title and abstract of all 114 studies were reviewed, and 36 duplicate studies were removed. Of the 78 remaining studies, 57 were excluded for the following reasons: study unrelated to the research question (n = 24), studies not published in the English language (n = 8), cost-effectiveness analyses (n = 6), studies comparing 2 types of allograft (n = 5), review papers with no original data (n = 4), animal studies (n = 4), papers focused on infection rates (n = 2), short follow-up (n = 2), 1 opinion/survey paper, and 1 paper utilizing nonstandard graft processing. This left a total of 21 comparative studies. Twelve of the 21 studies were excluded for not specifying whether the allografts had been irradiated (n = 6)2,21,22,25,29,33 or including allografts that had been irradiated (n = 6).6,11,26,36,37,39 The 9 remaining studies compared autograft and nonirradiated allograft tissue.‡ The reference section of each included study was reviewed to ensure that no studies were missed in the literature review. The literature search is summarized in Figure 1.

Figure 1.

Figure 1

Flowchart describing the literature search and study selection.

Data Extraction

Two authors (M.W.M. and D.M.) independently extracted all relevant data. These data included the study's country of origin, procedure date range, number of surgeons, number of eligible patients, percentage of eligible patients with follow-up, mean follow-up time, study design, patient demographics, whether the injury involved a sports mechanism, time from injury to reconstruction, graft choice, surgical technique and graft fixation, physical examination findings, the use of independent and/or blinded examiners, clinical failure rates, instrumented laxity measurements (KT-1000 or KT-2000 arthrometer), and patient-reported outcome scores.

Methodological Quality Assessment

Two authors (M.W.M. and D.M.) separately graded the methodological quality of each eligible study using the Delphi list quality score and modified Coleman methodology score. The Delphi scoring system was based on 9 questions: Was a method of randomization used? Was the treatment allocation concealed? Were the groups similar at baseline? Were eligibility criteria specified? Was the outcome assessor blinded? Was the care provider blinded? Was the patient blinded? Were point estimates and measures of variability used? Was there an intention-to-treat analysis? Each question was given 1 point for “yes,” 1 point was deducted for “no,” and 0 points were given for “don’t know.”42 The modified Coleman score included questions on study size, mean follow-up, percentage of patients with follow-up, number of interventions per group, study type, diagnostic certainty of ACL tear, description of ACL reconstruction procedure, description of postoperative rehabilitation, specifications of outcome criteria, procedures for assessing outcomes, and description of patient selection process.7,23 The modified Coleman methodology score was based on a scaled maximum of 100 points. The study's rating was considered excellent if the score was 85 to 100 points, good if it was 70 to 84 points, fair if it was 55 to 69 points, and poor if it was ≤54 points.

Statistical Analysis

Each outcome measure (graft failure as determined clinically or via instrumented laxity as well as patient-reported outcome scores) was qualitatively assessed for homogeneity. In cases of qualitative homogeneity, statistical testing of homogeneity (χ2) was performed. If the observed variation was inconsistent with the null hypothesis (P < .1), no meta-analysis was performed. In cases in which data were qualitatively heterogeneous, no statistical analysis of heterogeneity was performed. For outcome variables sufficiently homogeneous for meta-analysis, a Mantel-Haenszel analysis utilizing a random-effects model was used to pool results according to graft tissue (allograft vs autograft) while accounting for the number of patients in individual studies.35

RESULTS

Study Characteristics and Outcomes

Of the 9 included studies, 6 studies were level 29,17,20,32,38,40 and 3 studies were level 3.3,13,19 Of the 6 level 2 studies, 3 were randomized controlled trials20,38,40 (Table 1). Six of the 9 studies compared BPTB autografts and BPTB allografts. Two studies compared quadrupled hamstring tendon autografts and quadrupled hamstring tendon allografts, and 1 study compared quadrupled ham-string tendon autografts and anterior tibialis allografts (Table 2). The number of patients with follow-up ranged from 60 to 186. The mean follow-up duration ranged from 24 to 94 months. The mean patient age in 7 of 9 studies ranged from 24.5 to 32 years; 1 study reported a patient age of 40 to 54 years with no actual average, and another study did not report patient age (Table 3).

TABLE 1.

Study Descriptiona

Author Journal Year Country Procedure Date Range Determination of Treatment Level of Evidence
Sun et al40 AJSM 2011 China 2000-2004 Randomized 2
Lawhorn et al20 Arthroscopy 2012 USA 2002-2006 Randomized 2
Sun et al38 Arthroscopy 2009 China 2000-2004 Randomized 2
Edgar et al9 CORR 2008 USA 1997-2000 Patient choice 25%, randomized 75% 2
Barrett et al3 AJSM 2005 USA 1994-2000 Patient choice 3
Peterson et al32 Arthroscopy 2001 USA 1991-1992 Patient choice 2
Kleipool et al17 KSSTA 1998 Netherlands 1989-1991 Allograft availability 2
Harner et al13 CORR 1996 USA 1986-1989 Patient choice and allograft availability 3
Kustos et al19 Int Orthop 2004 Hungary 1996-2002 Patient choice 3
a

AJSM, American Journal of Sports Medicine; CORR, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research; Int Orthop, International Orthopaedics; KSSTA, Knee Surgery Sports Traumatology and Arthroscopy.

TABLE 2.

Surgical Detailsa

Author (Year) No. of Surgeons Autograft/Allograft Type Approach Femoral Fixation Tibial Fixation
Sun et al40 (2011) 1 Hamstring/hamstring Endoscopic Endobutton Interference screw plus staple
Lawhorn et al20 (2012) 5 Hamstring/tibialis anterior Endoscopic Cross pins Spiked washer and compression screw
Sun et al38 (2009) 1 BPTB/BPTB Endoscopic Interference screw Interference screw
Edgar et al9 (2008) 1 Hamstring/hamstring Endoscopic Endobutton plus interference screw Interference screw plus spiked washer and screw
Barrett et al3 (2005) 1 BPTB/BPTB Endoscopic Interference screw or Endobutton Interference screw/post, Endobutton/post, staple
Peterson et al32 (2001) 1 BPTB/BPTB Endoscopic Interference screw Interference screw
Kleipool et al17 (1998) 1 BPTB/BPTB Endoscopic Interference screw Interference screw
Harner et al13 (1996) 2 BPTB/BPTB 2 incision NR NR
Kustos et al19 (2004) NR BPTB/BPTB Endoscopic Interference screw Interference screw
a

BPTB, bone–patellar tendon–bone; NR, not reported.

TABLE 3.

Study Demographics and Follow-upa

Autograft Group
Allograft Group
Author (Year) Age, Mean (Range), y Sex, M:F, n Follow-up, Mean (Range), mo Follow-up,b % Age, Mean (Range), y Sex, M:F, n Follow-up, Mean (Range), mo Follow-up,b %
Sun et al40 (2011) 30 (19-56) 71:20 91 (72-120) 88 (91/104) 31 (18-59) 78:17 95 (72-120) 91 (95/104)
Lawhorn et al20 (2012) 32 (16-53) 32:22 24 72 33 (16-53) 38:10 24 67
Sun et al38 (2009) 32 (20-54) 61:15 67 (48-95) 88 33 (19-65) 63:17 67 (50-96) 93
Edgar et al9 (2008) 27 20:17 52 (38-70) 81 overall (37/NR) 31 26:20 48 (36-64) 81 overall (46/NR)
Barrett et al3 (2005) (40-54) 15:10 48 (24-99) 100 (25/25) (40-58) 20:18 36 (24-74) 100 (38/38)
Peterson et al32 (2001) 25 (15-43) 14:16 65 (57-78) 42 (30/71) 28 (15-55) 19:11 63 (55-73) 63 (30/48)
Kleipool et al17 (1998) 28 (16-38) 9:17 52 (42-74) 90 (26/29) 28 (14-43) 17:19 46 (30-64) 92 (36/39)
Harner et al13 (1996) NR 21:5 45 (30-75) 32 (26/82) NR 51:13 45 (30-75) 40 (64/162)
Kustos et al19 (2004) 24.5 22:4 38 (12-72) 100 (26/26) 25.6 38:14 38 (12-72) 100 (53/53)
a

NR, not reported.

b

Numbers (n) of total are in parentheses.

Clinical failure risk was reported in 6 of 9 studies, while instrumented laxity measurements were reported in 8 of 9 studies. Lachman test results were reported in 5 of 9 studies, and pivot-shift test results were reported in 7 of 9 studies. Patient-reported outcome scores were reported in all 9 studies and included the Lysholm, Cincinnati, International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) subjective, and Tegner activity scores.14,30,41

Study Methodological Quality

The Delphi list quality scores and the modified Coleman methodology scores were calculated for all 9 studies (see the Appendix, available in the online version of this article at http://ajsm.sagepub.com/supplemental). Based on the scaled maximum of 100 points, the mean overall modified Coleman score for the 9 studies was 67. Two studies were categorized as excellent, 1 study was categorized as good, 4 studies were categorized as fair, and 2 studies were categorized as poor.

Failure Risk

Clinical failure risk (as defined by the authors) was compared between autografts and allografts in 6 studies. According to this definition of failure, the overall failure risk across the 6 studies was 3.0% (6/198) in the autograft group and 2.4% (6/251) in the allograft group. Meta-analysis indicated no increased risk of graft failure in the allograft group (Figure 2).

Figure 2.

Figure 2

Forest plot of clinical failure risk for autografts versus allografts. The pooled odds ratio with 95% confidence intervals has been calculated with a Mantel-Haenszel (M-H) analysis utilizing a random-effects model.

Failure risk as determined by instrumented laxity measurements was compared between autografts and allografts in 8 studies. Failure was defined as anterior laxity of at least 5 mm greater than the contralateral side. According to this definition of failure, the overall failure risk across the 8 studies was 6.0% (22/364) in the autograft group and 5.5% (24/ 437) in the allograft group. Meta-analysis indicated no increased risk of graft failure in the allograft group (Figure 3).

Figure 3.

Figure 3

Forest plot of instrumented laxity failure risk for autografts versus allografts. The pooled odds ratio with 95% confidence intervals has been calculated with a Mantel-Haenszel analysis (M-H) utilizing a random-effects model.

Laxity on Physical Examination

Anterior laxity as assessed with the Lachman examination was reported in 5 studies. No study noted a statistically significant difference between the autograft and allograft groups (Table 4). Meta-analysis indicated no difference in the risk of having a Lachman grade greater than 0 between the 2 treatment groups (Figure 4).

TABLE 4.

Postoperative Lachman Results (in Percentages)a

Lachman Grade
Autograft
Allograft
Author (Year) 0 1 2 3 0 1 2 3 P Value
Sun et al40 (2011) 84 (76/91) 9 (8/91) 7.7 (7/91) 0 (0/91) 82 (78/95) 10 (9/95) 8 (8/95) 0 (0/95) NS
Sun et al38 (2009) 82 (62/76) 12 (9/76) 7 (5/76) 0 (0/76) 81 (65/80) 11 (9/80) 8 (6/80) 0 (0/80) NS
Barrett et al3 (2005) 96 (24/25) 4 (1/25) 0 (0/25) Not used 82 (31/38) 15 (6/38) 3 (1/38) Not used NS
Peterson et al32 (2001) 77 (23/30) 20 (6/30) 3 (1/30) Not used 80 (24/30) 10 (3/30) 10 (3/30) Not used NS
Kleipool et al17 (1998) 65 (17/26) 19 (5/26) 15 (4/26) 0 (0/26) 58 (21/36) 28 (10/36) 14 (5/36) 0 (0/36) NS
a

Numbers (n) of total are in parentheses.

NS, not significant.

Figure 4.

Figure 4

Forest plot of the risk of a Lachman grade greater than 0 for autografts versus allografts. The pooled odds ratio with 95% confidence intervals has been calculated with a Mantel-Haenszel (M-H) analysis utilizing a random-effects model.

Rotational laxity as assessed with the pivot-shift examination was reported in 5 studies. No study noted a statistically significant difference between the autograft and allograft groups (Table 5). Meta-analysis indicated no difference in the risk of having a pivot shift greater than 0 between the 2 treatment groups (Figure 5). The Harner et al13 study did not differentiate between a pivot shift of 0 and 1 and was not included in the meta-analysis.

TABLE 5.

Postoperative Pivot-Shift Results (in Percentages)a

Pivot-Shift Grade
Autograft
Allograft
Author (Year) 0 1 2 3 0 1 2 3 P Value
Sun et al40 (2011) 92 (84/91) 8 (7/91) 0 (0/91) 0 (0/91) 92 (87/95) 8.4 (8/95) 0 (0/95) 0 (0/95) NS
Lawhorn et al20 (2012) 89 (48/54) 9 (5/54) 0 (0/54) 2 (1/54) 92 (44/48) 8 (4/48) 0 (0/48) 0 (0/48) NS
Sun et al38 (2009) 93 (71/76) 7 (5/76) 0 (0/76) 0 (0/76) 93 (74/80) 8 (6/80) 0 (0/80) 0 (0/80) NS
Barrett et al3 (2005) 100 (25/25) 0 (0/25) 0 (0/25) Not used 89 (34/38) 8 (3/38) 3 (1/38) Not used NS
Peterson et al32 (2001) 90 (27/30) 7 (2/30) 3 (1/30) Not used 83 (25/30) 13 (4/30) 3 (1/30) Not used NS
Kleipool et al17 (1998) 73 (19/26) 23 (6/26) 4 (1/26) 0 (0/26) 78 (28/36) 14 (5/36) 8 (3/36) 0 (0/36) NS
Harner et al13 (1996) 92 (24/26) 8 (2/26) 89 (57/64) 11 (7/64) NS
a

Numbers (n) of total are in parentheses.

NS, not significant.

Figure 5.

Figure 5

Forest plot of the risk of a pivot shift greater than 0 for autografts versus allografts. The pooled odds ratio with 95% confidence intervals has been calculated with a Mantel-Haenszel (M-H) analysis utilizing a random-effects model.

Patient-Reported Outcome Scores

Patient-reported outcome scores were reported in every study. All studies used the Lysholm or subjective IKDC score. Five studies used both scoring systems. The Cincinnati knee score was also used in 3 of the 9 studies. The Tegner activity score was reported in 6 studies. There was no statistically significant difference between autograft and allograft reconstructions in any patient-reported outcome score in any study (Table 6).

TABLE 6.

Postoperative Patient-Reported Outcome Scoresa

Patient-Oriented Outcome Scores
Tegner Activity Scores
Author (Year) Form Autograft Allograft P Value Autograft Allograft P Value
Sun et al40 (2011) Lysholm 89 90 NS 7.7 7.6 NS
Lawhorn et al20 (2012) Cincinnati 90 91 NS
Sun et al38 (2009) IKDC subjective 91 91 NS
Edgar et al9 (2008) Lysholm 90 91 NS 7.8 7.6 NS
Barrett et al3 (2005) Cincinnati 91 92 NS
Peterson et al32 (2001) IKDC subjective 88 87 NS 6.8 6.9 NS
Kleipool et al17 (1998) Lysholm 91 93 NS
Harner et al13 (1996) Lysholm 92 91 NS 4.3 4.1 NS
Kustos et al19 (2004) Lysholm 89 90 NS 6.1 5.4 NS
a

IKDC, International Knee Documentation Committee; NS, not significant.

DISCUSSION

This systematic review is the first to compare outcomes of ACL reconstruction with autograft versus exclusively nonirradiated allograft tissue. This review demonstrates no statistically significant difference between autografts and nonirradiated allografts with regard to failure risk, physical examination findings, or patient-reported outcome scores. It is critically important to note that the results of this study can only be applied to patient populations that are similar to the patients included in the source studies. Mean patient age in the studies was generally in the late 20s to early 30s, with 1 study focused on patients in their 40s. It has also been shown that the risk of graft failure decreases with increasing age.16 Therefore, the studies in this systematic review did not evaluate allograft use in the highest risk population for graft failure, and this fact could bias the findings. Application of the findings of this study to a younger, more active population would not be appropriate.

Literature review demonstrated only 1 study that stratified outcomes based on age and activity level. Barrett et al2 showed at a minimum 2-year follow-up that patients younger than 25 years (mean age, 18 years) had significantly increased failure rates regardless of graft type. Reported failure rates for patients younger than 25 years were 12% for patellar tendon autografts, 25% for hamstring tendon auto-grafts, and 29% for allografts. In the allograft group, a combination of the patellar tendon and posterior tibialis were used, but it was not reported whether the allografts had been irradiated. In contrast, there was no statistically significant difference in failure rates among patients older than 25 years (mean age, 39 years) with different graft types.

The results of the current review are similar to previously published meta-analyses and systematic reviews comparing autograft and allograft usage in ACL reconstruction.5,10,18 The most recent review identified 31 prospective studies that included either autograft patients alone (27 studies) or autograft and allograft groups (4 studies).10 After pooling the data, the authors could not find any statistically significant difference in laxity or IKDC scores between groups. Although graft failure rates were noted to be 4.7 per 100 for autograft reconstructions and 8.2 per 100 for allograft reconstructions, this trend did not reach statistical significance. Carey et al5 included 9 autograft versus allograft comparative studies. Three of the studies included irradiated allografts, while 1 did not report whether irradiation was used. They showed no significant difference in Lysholm scores and instrumented laxity measurements between the groups. Clinical failure was noted in 5 of 230 clinical failures in the autograft group and 11 of 240 in the allograft group, which was not statistically significant. Krych et al18 performed a systematic review of 6 prospective nonrandomized cohort studies comparing patellar tendon autografts and patellar tendon allografts. When irradiated and chemically processed allografts were excluded, there was no significant difference in IKDC scores, Lachman/pivot-shift testing, graft rupture, or rate of reoperation.

Strengths of this study include the exclusive use of comparative studies and the inclusion of only studies that utilized nonirradiated allografts. These relatively homogeneous data allowed for meta-analysis and resulted in clear evidence that nonirradiated allografts do not compromise the results of ACL reconstruction in the population analyzed. The key limitation of this study is the inability to comment on the effect or role of nonirradiated allograft tissue in a younger, more active patient population. An additional limitation is that the majority of studies included in the review utilized patellar tendon grafts. It is unknown whether results would differ if younger patients and soft tissue grafts were more numerous in the dataset.

CONCLUSION

There were no significant differences in graft failure rate, postoperative laxity, or patient-reported outcome scores when comparing ACL reconstruction with autografts to nonirradiated allografts in this systematic review. These findings apply to patients in their late 20s and early 30s. We caution against extrapolating these findings to younger, more active cohorts.

Supplementary Material

Supplementary Data

An online CME course associated with this article is available for 1 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit™ at http://ajsm-cme.sagepub.com. In accordance with the standards of the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME), it is the policy of The American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine that authors, editors, and planners disclose to the learners all financial relationships during the past 12 months with any commercial interest (A ‘commercial interest’ is any entity producing, marketing, re-selling, or distributing health care goods or services consumed by, or used on, patients). Any and all disclosures are provided in the online journal CME area which is provided to all participants before they actually take the CME activity. In accordance with AOSSM policy, authors, editors, and planners’ participation in this educational activity will be predicated upon timely submission and review of AOSSM disclosure. Noncompliance will result in an author/editor or planner to be stricken from participating in this CME activity.

Acknowledgments

Research reported in this publication was supported by the National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases of the National Institutes of Health (award number K23AR063767). The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.

Footnotes

One or more of the authors has declared the following potential conflict of interest or source of funding

‡

References 3, 9, 13, 17, 19, 20, 32, 38, 40.

REFERENCES

  • 1.Asselmeier MA, Caspari RB, Bottenfield S. A review of allograft processing and sterilization techniques and their role in transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus. Am J Sports Med. 1993;21(2):170–175. doi: 10.1177/036354659302100202. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 2.Barrett AM, Craft JA, Replogle WH, Hydrick JM, Barrett GR. Anterior cruciate ligament graft failure: a comparison of graft type based on age and Tegner activity level. Am J Sports Med. 2011;39(10):2194–2198. doi: 10.1177/0363546511415655. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 3.Barrett G, Stokes D, White M. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in patients older than 40 years: allograft versus autograft patellar tendon. Am J Sports Med. 2005;33(10):1505–1512. doi: 10.1177/0363546504274202. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 4.Borchers JR, Pedroza A, Kaeding C. Activity level and graft type as risk factors for anterior cruciate ligament graft failure: a case-control study. Am J Sports Med. 2009;37(12):2362–2367. doi: 10.1177/0363546509340633. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 5.Carey JL, Dunn WR, Dahm DL, Zeger SL, Spindler KP. A systematic review of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with autograft compared with allograft. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2009;91(9):2242–2250. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.I.00610. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 6.Chang SK, Egami DK, Shaieb MD, Kan DM, Richardson AB. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: allograft versus autograft. Arthros-copy. 2003;19(5):453–462. doi: 10.1053/jars.2003.50103. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 7.Cowan J, Lozano-Calderon S, Ring D. Quality of prospective controlled randomized trials: analysis of trials of treatment for lateral epicondylitis as an example. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(8):1693–1699. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.F.00858. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 8.Curran AR, Adams DJ, Gill JL, Steiner ME, Scheller AD. The bio-mechanical effects of low-dose irradiation on bone-patellar tendon-bone allografts. Am J Sports Med. 2004;32(5):1131–1135. doi: 10.1177/0363546503260060. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 9.Edgar CM, Zimmer S, Kakar S, Jones H, Schepsis AA. Prospective comparison of auto and allograft hamstring tendon constructs for ACL reconstruction. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2008;466(9):2238–2246. doi: 10.1007/s11999-008-0305-5. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 10.Foster TE, Wolfe BL, Ryan S, Silvestri L, Kaye EK. Does the graft source really matter in the outcome of patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction? An evaluation of autograft versus allograft reconstruction results: a systematic review. Am J Sports Med. 2010;38(1):189–199. doi: 10.1177/0363546509356530. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 11.Guo L, Yang L, Duan XJ, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone graft: comparison of autograft, fresh-frozen allograft, and gamma-irradiated allograft. Arthroscopy. 2012;28(2):211–217. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2011.08.314. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 12.Harner CD, Fu FH. The immune response to allograft ACL reconstruction. Am J Knee Surg. 1993;6:45–46. [Google Scholar]
  • 13.Harner CD, Olson E, Irrgang JJ, Silverstein S, Fu FH, Silbey M. Allo-graft versus autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: 3- to 5-year outcome. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1996;324:134–144. doi: 10.1097/00003086-199603000-00016. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 14.Hefti F, Muller W, Jakob RP, Staubli HU. Evaluation of knee ligament injuries with the IKDC form. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1993;1(3-4):226–234. doi: 10.1007/BF01560215. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 15.Jackson DW, Grood ES, Goldstein JD, et al. A comparison of patellar tendon autograft and allograft used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the goat model. Am J Sports Med. 1993;21(2):176–185. doi: 10.1177/036354659302100203. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 16.Kaeding CC, Aros B, Pedroza A, et al. Allograft versus autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: predictors of failure from a MOON prospective longitudinal cohort. Sports Health. 2011;3(1):73–81. doi: 10.1177/1941738110386185. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 17.Kleipool AE, Zijl JA, Willems WJ. Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone allograft or autograft: a prospective study with an average follow up of 4 years. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1998;6(4):224–230. doi: 10.1007/s001670050104. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 18.Krych AJ, Jackson JD, Hoskin TL, Dahm DL. A meta-analysis of patellar tendon autograft versus patellar tendon allograft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Arthroscopy. 2008;24(3):292–298. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2007.08.029. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 19.Kustos T, Balint L, Than P, Bardos T. Comparative study of autograft or allograft in primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Int Orthop. 2004;28(5):290–293. doi: 10.1007/s00264-004-0568-8. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 20.Lawhorn KW, Howell SM, Traina SM, Gottlieb JE, Meade TD, Freed-berg HI. The effect of graft tissue on anterior cruciate ligament outcomes: a multicenter, prospective, randomized controlled trial comparing autograft hamstrings with fresh-frozen anterior tibialis allograft. Arthroscopy. 2012;28(8):1079–1086. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2012.05.010. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 21.Leal-Blanquet J, Alentorn-Geli E, Tuneu J, Valenti JR, Maestro A. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a multicenter prospective cohort study evaluating 3 different grafts using same bone drilling method. Clin J Sport Med. 2011;21(4):294–300. doi: 10.1097/JSM.0b013e31822153cb. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 22.Lee JH, Bae DK, Song SJ, Cho SM, Yoon KH. Comparison of clinical results and second-look arthroscopy findings after arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using 3 different types of grafts. Arthroscopy. 2010;26(1):41–49. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2009.06.026. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 23.Magnussen RA, Carey JL, Spindler KP. Does autograft choice determine intermediate-term outcome of ACL reconstruction? Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2011;19(3):462–472. doi: 10.1007/s00167-010-1277-z. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 24.Marx RG, Jones EC, Angel M, Wickiewicz TL, Warren RF. Beliefs and attitudes of members of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons regarding the treatment of anterior cruciate ligament injury. Arthroscopy. 2003;19(7):762–770. doi: 10.1016/s0749-8063(03)00398-0. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 25.Mascarenhas R, Tranovich M, Karpie JC, Irrgang JJ, Fu FH, Harner CD. Patellar tendon anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the high-demand patient: evaluation of autograft versus allograft reconstruction. Arthroscopy. 2010;26(9 Suppl):S58–S66. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2010.01.004. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 26.Mehta VM, Mandala C, Foster D, Petsche TS. Comparison of revision rates in bone-patella tendon-bone autograft and allograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Orthopedics. 2010;33(1):12. doi: 10.3928/01477447-20091124-15. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 27.Miller MD, Harner CD. The use of allograft: techniques and results. Clin Sports Med. 1993;12(4):757–770. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 28.Mirza F, Mai DD, Kirkley A, Fowler PJ, Amendola A. Management of injuries to the anterior cruciate ligament: results of a survey of orthopaedic surgeons in Canada. Clin J Sport Med. 2000;10(2):85–88. doi: 10.1097/00042752-200004000-00001. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 29.Noh JH, Yi SR, Song SJ, Kim SW, Kim W. Comparison between ham-string autograft and free tendon Achilles allograft: minimum 2-year follow-up after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using EndoButton and Intrafix. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2011;19(5):816–822. doi: 10.1007/s00167-010-1388-6. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 30.Noyes FR, Barber SD, Mooar LA. A rationale for assessing sports activity levels and limitations in knee disorders. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1989;246:238–249. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 31.Olson EJ, Harner CD, Fu FH, Silbey MB. Clinical use of fresh, frozen soft tissue allografts. Orthopedics. 1992;15(10):1225–1232. doi: 10.3928/0147-7447-19921001-13. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 32.Peterson RK, Shelton WR, Bomboy AL. Allograft versus autograft patellar tendon anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a 5-year follow-up. Arthroscopy. 2001;17(1):9–13. doi: 10.1053/jars.2001.19965. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 33.Prodromos C, Joyce B, Shi K. A meta-analysis of stability of auto-grafts compared to allografts after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2007;15(7):851–856. doi: 10.1007/s00167-007-0328-6. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 34.Rappe M, Horodyski M, Meister K, Indelicato PA. Nonirradiated versus irradiated Achilles allograft: in vivo failure comparison. Am J Sports Med. 2007;35(10):1653–1658. doi: 10.1177/0363546507302926. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 35.Review Manager (RevMan) [computer program]. Version 5.0. Copenhagen The Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration. 2008. [Google Scholar]
  • 36.Saddemi SR, Frogameni AD, Fenton PJ, Hartman J, Hartman W. Comparison of perioperative morbidity of anterior cruciate ligament autografts versus allografts. Arthroscopy. 1993;9(5):519–524. doi: 10.1016/s0749-8063(05)80398-6. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 37.Stringham DR, Pelmas CJ, Burks RT, Newman AP, Marcus RL. Comparison of anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions using patellar tendon autograft or allograft. Arthroscopy. 1996;12(4):414–421. doi: 10.1016/s0749-8063(96)90034-1. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 38.Sun K, Tian SQ, Zhang JH, Xia CS, Zhang CL, Yu TB. Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone auto-graft versus allograft. Arthroscopy. 2009;25(7):750–759. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2008.12.023. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 39.Sun K, Zhang J, Wang Y, et al. Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with at least 2.5 years’ follow-up comparing hamstring tendon autograft and irradiated allograft. Arthroscopy. 2011;27(9):1195–1202. doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2011.03.083. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 40.Sun K, Zhang J, Wang Y, et al. Arthroscopic reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with hamstring tendon autograft and fresh-frozen allograft: a prospective, randomized controlled study. Am J Sports Med. 2011;39(7):1430–1438. doi: 10.1177/0363546511400384. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 41.Tegner Y, Lysholm J. Rating systems in the evaluation of knee ligament injuries. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1985;198:43–49. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
  • 42.Verhagen AP, de Vet HC, de Bie RA, et al. The Delphi list: a criteria list for quality assessment of randomized clinical trials for conducting systematic reviews developed by Delphi consensus. J Clin Epidemiol. 1998;51(12):1235–1241. doi: 10.1016/s0895-4356(98)00131-0. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

Associated Data

This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.

Supplementary Materials

Supplementary Data

RESOURCES