Methods | RCT | |
Participants | Healthy postmenopausal women with above median serum testosterone (Italy) CVD risk: low Control: randomised 57, analysed at 6 months 55 Intervention: randomised 58, analysed at 6 months 51 Mean years in trial: control 4.38, intervention 4.28 % male: 0 Age: mean unclear (age range 48-69) |
|
Interventions | Reduced and modified fat vs usual diet Control aims: advised to increase fruit and vegetable intake Intervention aims: taught Sicilian diet including reduced total, saturated and omega–6 fats, increased blue fish (high in omega 3), increased whole cereals, legumes, seeds, fruit and vegetables Control methods: advice Intervention methods: taught Sicilian diet and cooking by professional chefs, with a weekly cooking course including social dinners Total fat intake (at 6 months): low & mod fat 30.9 (sd 11.4), cont 34.0 (sd 11.8)%E Saturated fat intake (at 6 months): low & mod fat 8.4 (sd 3.0), cont 11.2 (sd 5.0)%E Style: diet advice Setting: community |
|
Outcomes | Stated trial outcomes: breast cancer, weight, lipids, wellbeing Data available on total mortality? yes (no events) Cardiovascular mortality? yes (no events) Events available for combined cardiovascular events: cardiovascular deaths, non fatal MI, stroke, ventricular fibrillation, ventricular overload Secondary outcomes: total and non-fatal MI, stroke, cancer diagnoses and deaths (events only for stroke and cancer diagnoses) Tertiary outcomes: none |
|
Notes | ||
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors’ judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | “individually randomised” |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Randomisation method not clearly described |
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) All outcomes |
High risk | Participants were aware of assignment, researchers unclear |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes |
Unclear risk | Unclear, deaths, cancer and CV events are drop-outs, trialists asked for data - unclear if any data missing |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Low risk | Not relevant for primary and secondary outcomes as all trialists asked for data |
Other bias | Low risk | |
Free of systematic difference in care? | High risk | Intensive cookery course with social element compared with briefadvice. See Control and Intervention Methods in Interventions section of the Table of Characteristics of Included Studies |
Free of dietary differences other than fat? | High risk | Both groups encouraged to increase fruit and vegetables, but intervention group also encouraged to increase fish, pulses, seeds, whole grains |