Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Psychoneuroendocrinology. 2014 Aug 12;49:299–309. doi: 10.1016/j.psyneuen.2014.07.022

Table 1.

Four kinds of reliability (Cranford et al., 2006), with descriptions and design examples

Description Design Decision Question Empirical Example
I. Between
subjects at the
same occasion
of measurement
Cross-sectional,
single
occasion
How many days of data are
required to construct a
reliable measure of
differences between people
measured at the same
occasion?
Finding: Education correlated
negatively with diurnal
cortisol slope (Cohen et al., 2006).
Sampling: 5 samples per day,
1 day, 781 participants
II. Between
subjects at
different
occasions of
measurement
Cross-sectional,
different
occasions
How many days of data are
required to construct a
reliable measure of between
people measured at different
occasions?
Finding: Psychological and
sleep variables measured once
were unrelated to diurnal
cortisol mean, slope, or AUC
measured once in breast
cancer patients at varied
points post-diagnosis (Carlson et al., 2007)
Sampling: 4 samples per day,
1 day, 33 participants
III. Between
subjects across
multiple
occasions
Longitudinal
or repeated
measures,
multiple
occasions
How many days of data over
how many time points are
required construct a reliable
measure of stable differences
between people?
Finding: A personality
subscale of the SCL-90
measured at one time point
significantly correlated with
mean basal cortisol levels
averaged across 3–6 years
(Lupien et al., 1996)
Sampling: 24 samples per day,
1 day, 3–6 occasions, 19
participants
IV. Within
subjects,
change across
occasions
Longitudinal
or repeated
measures,
multiple
occasions
How many days of data at
each time point are required
construct a reliable measure
of differences between
occasions within the same
person?
Finding: Foster children
receiving an intervention had
steeper diurnal cortisol slopes
over time; children in regular
foster care had flatter slopes
over time (Fisher et al., 2007).
Sampling: 2 samples per day,
2 days, 12 occasions, 117
participants
Note: A latent variable was
used to isolate occasion from
day variance

Note: See Kudielka and colleagues (2012) for design considerations regarding within-day research questions such as those associated with ecological momentary assessment