Table 1.
Author | Participants | Motor behavior | Method | Auditory stimuli | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Birns et al. (1965) | 20 newborns; age range: 36–96 h | Body movements | 12 trials; online rating of behavioral excitation | Continuous tone (85/90 db) vs. intermittent tone (85 db) vs. silence | The (aroused) newborns were differentially soothed by auditory stimuli. Greater decrease of activity and level of arousal for low-pitch than high-pitch tone |
Condon and Sander (1974) | 16 newborns; age range: 12 h-14 days | Body movements | 1 session; frame-by-frame analysis (30 frames/s) | Male voice (talking) | Synchrony between auditory stimuli and body movements |
Collyer and Bench (1974) | 11 newborns; age range: 2–8 days | Body movements | Video recordings during 6 trials (3/ear); coding of behavior/activity state | Sound (70 db) during 5 s vs. during 60 s vs. silence | Higher activity states at the onset of sound than in the silence conditions |
Thelen (1979) | 20 infants; age range: 28–52 weeks | Body movements | Observation of body movements | Babble | Peak in rhythmic arm activity at the same age when they begin to babble (4 months) |
Kato et al. (1983) | 32 newborns; age range: 1–6 days | Body movements | 30 h video recording of leg/arm movements (73 selected periods) | Human voice (spoken to) vs. non-human sound (noise) | Body movement reaction to human voice but not to non-human sound. Newborns can correlate movements with different voices |
Miller and Byrne (1983) | 24 newborns; age range: 30 72 h | Body movements | Heart rate measurement; coding of behavioral state and body activity during light sleeping | Sound varying in: (1) duration of the transition and (2) pulsed vs. continuous | Heart rate increased but no significant differences in body activity as an effect of auditory stimuli |
Rönnqvist and von Hofsten (1994) | 26 newborns; age range: 2–6 days | Arm-, hand-, finger movements | Video recording, three conditions: baseline (no stimuli), social (face to face with mother), object (ball moving in front of newborn) | Talking interaction with mother (social condition) and rattle sound attached to the object (object condition) | Different movement patterns between conditions. More finger movements, transitional, and flexion movements of hand in the social condition and more thumb-index finger activity and whole hand extension in the object condition |
Locke et al. (1995) | 61 infants average age from 18.4 to 37.5 weeks-old | Manual activity | Audio and video recording | Audible or inaudible rattles | Increased shaking in infants who had begun to babble |
Ejiri (1998) | 28 infants; age range: 5–9 months | Arms shaking | Video recording | Audible or inaudible rattles | Rhythmic activities reached their peak around the onset of canonical babbling |
Dibiasi and Einspieler (2002) | 29 infants; age range: 9–14 weeks | Body movements | Video recordings of spontaneous movements | Sound (68/77/88db) vs. silence | Tendency to decrease/stop movements in the acoustic (88dB) compared to the silence condition |
Iverson and Fagan (2004) | 47 infants from 6 to 9 months-old | Body movements | Video recordings during semi-structured play session | Vocalization | Manual activities are linked with communicative gesture-speech system |
Nakata and Trehub (2004) | 43 infants; age range: 5.5–6.5 months | Body movements | Audiovisual presentation (4 min segments); video recording; coding of minimal body movement | Mother talking vs. mother singing | Reduction of body movements shown more often in the mother singing than mother talking condition |
Iverson et al. (2007) | 26 infants; age range: 4–7 months | Arms shaking and laterality biases | Play with infants rattles (video recorded) | Rattle with and without sound | Rate of rattle shaking increased from the pre-babble to the babble onset session |
Iverson (2010) | NA | NA | Literature review | NA | Motor development is participatory in the emergence of language |
Zentner and Eerola (2010) | 120 infants; age range: 5–24 months | Body movements | Video recordings and kinematic recordings of body movements; coding of body movement engagement | Eight music/rhythm stimuli: two excerpts of classical music, rhythm-only version of classical music excerpts, children’s music, isochronous drumbeats, music stimulus with rapid tempo shifts vs. two control stimuli: adult-directed speech and infant-directed speech (65 db) | More rhythmic movements to music/rhythm than speech, some tempo flexibility, and more rhythmic coordination with displays of positive affect. Youngest infants (5–7 months) less consistent in behavior than older (less overall rhythmic movements and as much movement to infant-directed speech as to music/rhythm stimuli) |
Morgan et al. (2013) | 51 infants; age range: 4–7 months | Body movements | Video recording during 1 (10 min) session; coding of level of body activity | Classical music and movie vs. classical music and static image | All infants displayed body movements with music (but not rhythmic movements). More movements in the static image than movie condition |
van der Meer and van der Weel (2011) | NA; age range: 3–6 weeks | Arm movements | Sound presentation from speakers attached to right/left wrist; measurement of distance between ipsilateral wrist and ear | Mother talking | Decreased distance between the wrist and ear at the side of sound presentation, indicating intentional control of arm |
Lee and Newell (2013) | 11 infants; age range: 10–16 weeks | Arm movements | Biweekly observations; 6 trials (60 s); kinematic recordings of right arm-hand movements | Mother’s voice vs. musical tones vs. silence | Both auditory stimuli conditions increased amplitude of arm movements and number of reaches compared with the silence condition |
Fujii et al. (2014) | 30 infants; age range: 3–4 months | Limb movements and vocalization | Video recordings and kinematic recordings of limb movements with simultaneous sound recordings of vocalization | Music (beats) or silence | Limb movements and vocalization synchronized to the music |
NA, information not available; db, decibel; s, seconds; ms, milliseconds; EMG, electromyography.