Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Sep 21.
Published in final edited form as: Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010 Apr 14;(4):CD005533. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005533.pub2
Methods Parallel-group, multicentre study (246 centres in 22 countries). Three treatment groups: BUD; BUD/F and BUD/F (with BUD/F also as reliever)
Jadad quality score: 4
Participants Symptomatic asthmatic adults and children
% ELIGIBLE OF SCREENED POPULATION: Not reported
% RUN-IN PARTICIPANTS RANDOMISED: 85
RANDOMISED: 1835 (BUD: 926; BUD/F: 909)
WITHDRAWALS: BUD/F: 148; BUD: 142
AGE mean (range): 35 (4 to 79)
GENDER (% male): 44
SEVERITY: Moderate
BASELINE % PREDICTED FEV1 (mean): 73
BASELINE DOSE OF ICS: 615 mcg/d
ASTHMA DURATION: 9 years
ATOPY (%): Not reported
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: 4 to 80 years; treatment with 400 to 1000 mcg/d ICS (200 to 500 mcg/d for participants aged 4 to 11 years) for 3 or more months; FEV1 predicted 60% to 100%; 12 or more inhalations during last 10 days of run-in (8 for participants aged 4 to 11 years)
EXCLUSION CRITERIA: Participants using 10 or more inhalations on one day during run-in (7 or more for participants aged 4 to 11 years); participants experiencing an exacerbation of asthma during run-in period
Interventions LABA + ICS versus INCREASED dose ICS
OUTCOMES: TIMING 12 months
RUN-IN: 14 to 18 days
DOSE OF ICS DURING RUN-IN: Same as pre-study ICS dose (+ terbutaline)
INTERVENTION PERIOD: 12 months
TEST GROUP: Combination budesonide and formoterol (100/6 mcg) bid
CONTROL GROUP: Budesonide 400 mcg bid (plus as needed terbutaline)
DEVICE: Turbohaler
NUMBER OF DEVICES: 1
COMPLIANCE: Self-reported compliance on 84% of days; self-reported non-compliance on 3% of days; incomplete records on 13% of days
CO-TREATMENT: prn SABA
Outcomes PULMONARY FUNCTION TEST: FEV1; am PEF; pm PEF
SYMPTOM SCORES: Daytime scores; nighttime scores; % symptom-free days
FUNCTIONAL STATUS: Exacerbations (treated with oral steroids, hospitalisation or ED visit)*; rescue medication use; night awakenings
INFLAMMATORY MARKERS: Not reported
ADVERSE EFFECTS: Reported
WITHDRAWALS: Reported
Primary outcome measure*
Notes Full-text publication
Source of funding Astra Zeneca
Confirmation of methodology and data: Requested, obtained for adults. Data on children were requested directly from the study sponsors concurrently. The data for OCS-treated exacerbations for children were not available User defined number: 800
Risk of bias
Item Authors’ judgement Description
Adequate sequence generation? Yes Computer-generated randomisation scheme
Allocation concealment? Unclear Eligible patients were randomised in balanced blocks by allocating patient numbers in consecutive order
Blinding?
All outcomes
Yes Double-blind; identical inhaler devices used
Incomplete outcome data addressed?
All outcomes
Unclear “All analyses were performed on an intention-to-treat basis.” Additional information on the composition of the ITT population was not provided
Free of selective reporting? Yes Data on OCS-treated exacerbations reported as composite with ED visits/hospitalisations, PEF falls and requirement for medical intervention. Separate data for OCS-treated exacerbations and hospital admission received. Data on adults were received from study sponsors directly. We requested data for children from the study sponsors concurrently but these were not available