Skip to main content
. 2014 Sep 22;9(9):e107494. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0107494

Table 3. Reproducibility of detecting differences in dystrophin expression in muscle biopsies with a wide range of dystrophin levels from healthy controls to BMD and DMD samples by immunofluorescence using MANDYS106 antibody and Definiens intensity measurements (at ‘control’ microscope settings).

Sample Experiment Number of sections Number of fibers analyzed Cross sectional area of individual fibers; Mean ± SD (x103 µm2) Dystrophin membrane intensity MANDYS106 (au)
Mean Intra-assay precision CV% sections Inter-assay precision CV% experiments Q90 mean Maximum Ranking
Control 2 1 2 625 4.4±1.8 929 13% 13% 2397 3609 1
2 2 544 4.3±1.9 768 3% 2169 3640 1
BMD 1 1 2 262 4.8±2.7 415 3% 9% 1224 2425 2
2 2 337 4.9±2.2 367 6% 1076 2195 3
BMD 3 1 2 173 7.2±3.6 387 13% 4% 1125 2366 3
2 2 221 7.2±3.8 412 7% 1195 2439 2
BMD 4 1 2 250 5.8±3.9 359 4% 7% 1062 2152 4
2 2 102 7.7±4.9 323 6% 993 2122 4
BMD 2 1 2 300 4.4±3.3 200 7% 4% 668 1553 5
2 2 197 6.4±4.2 213 4% 689 1552 5
DMD 1 1 2 1102 2.3±1.1 58 6% 24% 154 341 6
2 2 739 3.0±1.8 82 13% 198 399 6
DMD 2 1 2 937 2.6±1.5 44 10% 43% 115 243 7
2 2 816 2.5±1.4 82 6% 184 334 7

The intra-assay precision (CV%) was calculated for the mean dystrophin intensity of multiple sections of a biopsy/sample analyzed in the same experiment. Inter-assay precision between experiments performed on different days was assessed in two ways by ranking of the samples based on the dystrophin intensity in each experiment and by calculating the CV% from the mean dystrophin intensity in each experiment (experiment 1 and 2 performed 102 days apart).

BMD, Becker muscular dystrophy; CV, coefficient of variation; DMD, Duchenne muscular dystrophy; SD, standard deviation.